Fox’s The Following was one of 2013′s biggest television surprises. After 14 narrative-heavy episodes, the season finale left us with our jaws on the floor. Just when viewers thought that Ryan Hardy (Kevin Bacon) and Claire (Natalie Zea) had survived the Joe Carroll (Jame Purefoy) ordeal and were heading swiftly toward happily ever after, the compelling freshman season ended with a shocker that put an abrupt halt to that thought process, and left a lot of loose ends in its stead.
In a stunning example of storytelling at its peak, The Following returned with a season two opener that simply put made you cringe with expectation. After a short (recent) history lesson that answered any lingering questions from last season’s finale (and officially killed Claire off), we picked back up with our cast (or those who made it through season one alive) one year later, on the anniversary of Carroll’s alleged death – a date that should predictably make people in the world created by The Following a little on the nervous side.
Ryan is now the lone survivor of the final attack made by the original cult of Joe Carroll, and Mike (Shawn Ashmore) is holed up in Virginia dealing with the repercussions of it all. Both of these men took a significant beating, physically and emotionally in season one, which was still evident when we reunited with them after all this time. Although they largely shared in many of the more painful events leading up to Carroll’s defeat, in the time lapse between season one and two, it’s pretty obvious that they haven’t spent much time together. Other than a one-time run in at a bar, not completely at random, Mike’s attempts to reach out have been exclusively one-sided.
It’s not until a new cult makes a very dramatic introduction to the public that Ryan and Mike are pulled back into the thick of things, courtesy of the FBI. It’s also at this point in the episode that we are clued in to the fact that despite Ryan’s outward apathy toward the case and anything Joe Carroll-related, he has continued to follow it closely – not unlike Mike, except in a more closet psychopath type of way. For now, at least, these two men will be proceeding with the investigation from different sides; Mike is back with the FBI as a consultant on the case, whereas Ryan has chosen to avoid the bureau’s legal red tape this time around.
I suspect that part of Ryan’s motivation for remaining in New York had something to do with him thinking (read: paranoia) that Joe Carroll was in fact still alive. Although, we were also introduced to Ryan’s niece, Max (Jessica Stroup), on this episode. I’m pretty sure we were mislead to believe his only family member was an older sister, but it looks like she has a daughter. I have to admit though that it’s almost entirely too convenient that she happens to be in law enforcement considering his current lack of insider information.
Continue reading on the next page…Next
There are some interesting dynamics at play in the new season of The Following. The characters are still in a state where it’s hard to know who to trust – anyone could be a member of this new cult – but there also appears to be a separation between the new and old cult.
Emma (Valorie Curry) is back this season as one of the eight surviving members of the original cult who hasn’t been caught or killed yet. In the first scene where we are reunited with her, she seems to be conflicted about the events that took place on the subway. We know that last season she wasn’t privy to every move that was made, and that was common practice in order to keep anyone with loose lips from being able to put the master plan in jeopardy. However, there’s almost a tinge of disgust when she speaks. If anything, she definitely doesn’t like the idea that there is a new set of followers out there that are making a go at it on their own. It’s almost like she can smell the disrespect intended.
As one of the original followers, Emma was close (more like in love) with Joe. Since we can’t be sure whether or not she knows he’s actually still alive, the attack on the subway would probably make her feel like there were amateurs attempting to disrespect his memory. Still, she’s intrigued (err, angered) enough to risk checking out a potential lead. I’d wager if she had been the one to find Carlos and put the pieces together, he wouldn’t have been able to walk out of that apartment, let alone run. Emma may look like someone that can be pushed around, but I wouldn’t suggest messing with her.
Since Emma is one of the few cult members still alive from round one, she doesn’t have many allies going into season two and she’s already set in strict contrast to the new followers. We got our first glimpse at what appears to be some of the key players in the new cult – and they don’t seem to harbor warm feelings for anyone that was with Joe in Havenport. The way the twins treated Carlos after he is discovered by Ryan is similar to how you’d treat a small child, not someone you have any sense of reverence for.
Are these cult members a colder version of the followers we saw in Season 1? How will Carroll react to this blatant message? Do you think Ryan and Mike will end up working this case together? Let us know all your theories on The Following in the comment section below!
Season 2 Predictions:
- We’ll find out that Max’s new boyfriend is in the new cult.
- Max and Mike will meet, sparks will fly, and that will be all she wrote.
- Joe Carroll will return to NY.
- Carroll and Hardy will end up working together to stop the cult.
- Emma will die at the hands of the new cult members.