carrie fisher rogue one

‘Star Wars’ fans argue over de-aging not being used, proving nobody ever wins

Do you think digital de-aging is over-used in 'Star Wars' now-a-days?

Warning: the article contains spoilers for Obi-Wan Kenobi episode five.

Recommended Videos

The debate rages on amongst Star Wars fans about whether the use of digitally de-aging actors is a good thing or a bad thing, with the latest hot take being that perhaps we don’t need to overly rely on computer-generated imagery constantly to make such an effect come to life.

Back in 2016, the age-accurate likenesses of Peter Cushing’s Grand Moff Tarkin and Carrie Fisher’s Princess Leia were recreated in Rogue One. In Cushing’s case, it was done years after he passed away. Ever since then, the debate has raged within the Star Wars fandom about when it is appropriate to use digital de-aging and when it isn’t appropriate.

Warning: the following contains spoilers for Obi-Wan Kenobi episode five.

In Obi-Wan Kenobi episode five, Hayden Christensen appears — sans Darth Vader helmet — in a flashback scene sparring opposite Ewan McGregor’s titular hero.

The fan service was unsurprisingly a slam dunk with viewers.

However, it struck some viewers that Christensen didn’t look like he got the same digital makeover treatment as Cushing in Rogue One, for example, despite the scene taking place during a period when the actor was roughly 20 years younger than he is now.

One fan, a Reddit user by the name of u/TizAConicidence, even posted a video in which he created a deep fake of Christensen to make him look appropriately younger as a padawan. The result was pretty impressive, for a self-admitted amateur attempt.

Although the use of CGI de-aging — or lack thereof — has not been officially confirmed by Disney one way or another, ScreenRant hypothesized the Mouse House likely did use digital makeover techniques lightly in the scene, just to a lesser extent than what we’ve seen in the past. The article’s reasoning was that the scene focused more on choreography and lightsaber dueling, rather than lingering on close-ups for too long, so there was less of an emphasis on digital de-aging for the purpose of that particular story beat. What’s more, Christensen has aged rather gracefully over the years, so he arguably doesn’t need anything more than a touch-up here and there with the digital makeup brush for extreme close-ups.

Another Reddit user, u/Shakyyy, proclaimed they were “glad” Disney didn’t “overly de-age Anakin the dueling flashback with Obi-Wan.”

“I get the criticism, he doesn’t look 19 and you can tell how much hes aged but its a price I’m willing to pay. I’ve seen some fan edits of him de-aged and they look good but it just doesn’t compare, it just felt right to me that it was actually Hayden Christensen, real and completely natural portraying Anakin Skywalker again. Even all these years later he’s still got that damn smile.”

This likely won’t be the last time a beloved Star Wars character will face the prospect of getting digitally de-aged. But given the fairly positive reception of episode five of Obi-Wan Kenobi, perhaps moderation is the key.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more
related content
Read Article What happened to Bernard Hill while shooting ‘The Lord of the Rings?’ His dangerous encounters, explained
Bernard Hill as King Theoden in the Battle of Helm's Deep from The Lord of the Rings
Read Article ‘Star Wars’ braved intense hatred so that Marvel’s Thanos could snap Wanda into dust in ‘Avengers: Infinity War’
Star Wars
Read Article Giancarlo Esposito officially joins MCU, but the crucial point of his deal has already disappeared into oblivion
Giancarlo Esposito joins MCU
Read Article Latest Marvel News: Ben Affleck threatens to invade the MCU as Kevin Feige calls out his big problem with ‘Deadpool 3’ — and he’s got a point
Deadpool forms a frame with his hands with Charlie Cox's Daredevil and Ben Affleck's Daredevil behind him
Read Article Hugh Jackman’s legendary new role might just make Taron Egerton more likely to become the next Wolverine
Taron Egerton and Hugh Jackman arrive for the European premiere of 'Eddie The Eagle' at Odeon Leicester Square on March 17, 2016 in London, England.
Related Content
Read Article What happened to Bernard Hill while shooting ‘The Lord of the Rings?’ His dangerous encounters, explained
Bernard Hill as King Theoden in the Battle of Helm's Deep from The Lord of the Rings
Read Article ‘Star Wars’ braved intense hatred so that Marvel’s Thanos could snap Wanda into dust in ‘Avengers: Infinity War’
Star Wars
Read Article Giancarlo Esposito officially joins MCU, but the crucial point of his deal has already disappeared into oblivion
Giancarlo Esposito joins MCU
Read Article Latest Marvel News: Ben Affleck threatens to invade the MCU as Kevin Feige calls out his big problem with ‘Deadpool 3’ — and he’s got a point
Deadpool forms a frame with his hands with Charlie Cox's Daredevil and Ben Affleck's Daredevil behind him
Read Article Hugh Jackman’s legendary new role might just make Taron Egerton more likely to become the next Wolverine
Taron Egerton and Hugh Jackman arrive for the European premiere of 'Eddie The Eagle' at Odeon Leicester Square on March 17, 2016 in London, England.
Author
Danny Peterson
Danny Peterson covers entertainment news for WGTC and has previously enjoyed writing about housing, homelessness, the coronavirus pandemic, historic 2020 Oregon wildfires, and racial justice protests. Originally from Juneau, Alaska, Danny received his Bachelor's degree in English Literature from the University of Alaska Southeast and a Master's in Multimedia Journalism from the University of Oregon. He has written for The Portland Observer, worked as a digital enterprise reporter at KOIN 6 News, and is the co-producer of the award-winning documentary 'Escape from Eagle Creek.'