Toaster, The Brave Little Toaster (1987)
Image via Hyperion Pictures

Lost horror fans name the non-horror movies that terrified them

There's an imposter among us.

For those of you old enough to remember, there was a certain spell of time where an animated children’s film had a good to fair chance of including one or three scenes that would go on to form the basis of many a child’s nightmares for the better part of their young life; Dumbo‘s wine-induced hallucination sequence comes to mind, as does the entire runtime of The Secret of NIMH.

Recommended Videos

Of course, this has never been limited to children’s animated movies (although it is peculiar that such a genre is the standout); there have been plenty of films over the years that, while they weren’t marketed as horror movies, still managed to carry out such an effect on its viewers, and r/horror has taken to naming some of the most heinous offenders.

The original poster offered up The Brave Little Toaster and its infamous clown scene as a chief suspect for the crime of subsequent night terrors. Plenty of others readily nodded in agreement, with one, in particular, pointing an extra finger at the film’s junkyard scene.

One user made the jump to live-action and admitted that A24’s 1917 got to them in bone-chilling ways; a warzone on its own is nothing warm and fuzzy, but the sequence in No Man’s Land could certainly launch it into the even more disturbing heights.

Another responder found themselves in a joking mood and suggested Suicide Squad, not because the film itself was scary, but because knowing that someone in the world was willing to release it, was scary.

And meeting in the middle with a live-action children’s film, one other user pointed to The NeverEnding Story; stop-motion on its own can elicit some shudders in a few viewers, but this classic family film is all too happy to tango with our trauma directly.

Usually, one might be happy with the scenario of a film catching them off-guard, but non-horror films that give the gift of cold sweats might just be the exception to that.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more
related content
Read Article Giancarlo Esposito officially joins MCU, but the crucial point of his deal has already disappeared into oblivion
Giancarlo Esposito joins MCU
Read Article Latest Marvel News: Ben Affleck threatens to invade the MCU as Kevin Feige calls out his big problem with ‘Deadpool 3’ — and he’s got a point
Deadpool forms a frame with his hands with Charlie Cox's Daredevil and Ben Affleck's Daredevil behind him
Read Article Hugh Jackman’s legendary new role might just make Taron Egerton more likely to become the next Wolverine
Taron Egerton and Hugh Jackman arrive for the European premiere of 'Eddie The Eagle' at Odeon Leicester Square on March 17, 2016 in London, England.
Read Article ‘The Idea Of You’: Is August Moon A Real Band?
Nicholas Galitzine as 'Hayes Campbell', Raymond Cham Jr. as 'Oliver', Jaiden Anthony as 'Adrian', Viktor White as 'Simon' and Dakota Adan as 'Rory' star in THE IDEA OF YOU
Read Article Marvel confirms controversial ‘Captain America 4’ leak, and now everyone’s saying the same thing
Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson wields the Captain America shield superimposed over an orange-hued poster for Avengers: Endgame
Related Content
Read Article Giancarlo Esposito officially joins MCU, but the crucial point of his deal has already disappeared into oblivion
Giancarlo Esposito joins MCU
Read Article Latest Marvel News: Ben Affleck threatens to invade the MCU as Kevin Feige calls out his big problem with ‘Deadpool 3’ — and he’s got a point
Deadpool forms a frame with his hands with Charlie Cox's Daredevil and Ben Affleck's Daredevil behind him
Read Article Hugh Jackman’s legendary new role might just make Taron Egerton more likely to become the next Wolverine
Taron Egerton and Hugh Jackman arrive for the European premiere of 'Eddie The Eagle' at Odeon Leicester Square on March 17, 2016 in London, England.
Read Article ‘The Idea Of You’: Is August Moon A Real Band?
Nicholas Galitzine as 'Hayes Campbell', Raymond Cham Jr. as 'Oliver', Jaiden Anthony as 'Adrian', Viktor White as 'Simon' and Dakota Adan as 'Rory' star in THE IDEA OF YOU
Read Article Marvel confirms controversial ‘Captain America 4’ leak, and now everyone’s saying the same thing
Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson wields the Captain America shield superimposed over an orange-hued poster for Avengers: Endgame
Author
Charlotte Simmons
Charlotte is a freelance writer for We Got This Covered, a graduate of St. Thomas University's English program, a fountain of film opinions, and probably the single biggest fan of Peter Jackson's 'King Kong.' Having written professionally since 2018, her work has also appeared in The Town Crier and The East.