Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.
Photo montage of Taylor Swift and Scott Borchetta at the 56th annual GRAMMY Awards Pre-GRAMMY Gala and at Nashville's Bluebird Café in 2004.
Photo by Kevin Mazur/WireImage/via Scott Borchetta/Instagram

‘STAY AWAY FROM HER’: Taylor Swift fans aren’t buying Scott Borchetta’s ‘fake’ attempt to make amends

The denial is strong with this one.

Sunday, Nov. 3, marked 20 years since Big Machine Records founder Scott Borchetta met a 14-year-old Taylor Swift. The music mogul decided to celebrate the occasion despite his shaky relationship with the pop star, and her fans weren’t too pleased.

Recommended Videos

Borchetta started his homage, which he posted to his Instagram page, by referring to the Beatles’ 1987 documentary It Was Twenty Years Ago Today, saying the association between the legendary English rock band and Swift isn’t “too far off the mark.” The praise didn’t end there as the record executive remembered a day that “changed both of [their] lives,” and proclaimed his pride in the “art and the work [Swift, whom he refers to simply as “T,”] did while [they] were together.”

Why Taylor Swift may not feel as warmly toward Scott Borchetta as he does toward her

The same art and work mentioned by Borchetta in his post became the focus of a heated, public dispute in 2019 between the man who discovered Swift and the artist who would turn his local-sized label into a massive music industry player. When Swift joined Big Machine Records in 2005, shortly after the fateful performance pictured in Borchetta’s post, she, like many artists, signed away the ownership of the masters of her first six albums.

The musician tried to buy them when her contract expired in 2018 but, according to a statement she released a year later, was only ever offered a deal that would force her to “‘earn’ one album back at a time, one for every new one [she] turned in.” If that hadn’t harmed her relationship with Borchetta enough, then it was basically severed when, in 2019, he decided to sell Big Machine, along with the rights to all of Swift’s music, to Scooter Braun, a man who had played a hand in Kanye West and Kim Kardashian’s takedown of Swift in 2016. Swift called this outcome her “worst case scenario.”

It makes sense, then, why Swifties didn’t take too kindly to the 62-year-old’s sugar-coated, white-washing attempt which, to make matters worse, was liked by Braun. “STAY AWAY FROM HER,” one fan shouted, with another displaying pristine gif usage abilities. Thank you, Will Smith.

https://twitter.com/gu1ltyas1n/status/1853337702219047202
https://twitter.com/kelseyjbarnes/status/1853214077167808773

“He can f— right off with his fake sentiment. 20 years ago, he took advantage of a young girl who didn’t know any better, so he could rob her when she got successful,” a third Swiftie expressed, referring to the exploitative contract Swift was offered as a teenager. Many were outraged on the singer’s behalf, saying “Taylor is much classier than I am bc u [sic] would see me on the news and not for good reason.”

https://twitter.com/Taizsia_Twx/status/1853333430085534193
https://twitter.com/lqveroni/status/1853458811601969409

Borchetta finished his dedication by saying he was equally proud of the work Swift is doing now. “Keep crushing it,” he toasted, virtually. It’s hard to look past the irony of these words considering the artist’s recent earth-shattering success is intrinsically tied to her effort of remaking and republishing the six albums Borchetta sold away. After the dispute, the music industry and public opinion sided predominantly with Swift. Now favored by the masses, her remasters, which she aptly titled “Taylor’s Version,” catapulted her back catalog to heights previously untapped as audiences and critics alike got to rediscover her work.

Though fans hoped the success of the “Taylor’s Version” albums would reduce the value of Swift’s old masters, an investigation by Music Business Worldwide suggested that the singer’s universal popularity has benefitted not just herself, but Borchetta, Braun, and the current owners of her first six albums, the Disney family’s investment firm, Shamrock Holdings.

Borchetta hadn’t addressed Swift this publicly for years, and the singer has yet to acknowledge the post. Could this be the start of a “Bury the Hatchet” Era for the global superstar and the music executive?

Hottest Electronics On Amazon This Week


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Author
Image of Francisca Tinoco
Francisca Tinoco
Francisca is a pop culture enthusiast and film expert. Her Bachelor's Degree in Communication Sciences from Nova University in Portugal and Master's Degree in Film Studies from Oxford Brookes University in the UK have allowed her to combine her love for writing with her love for the movies. She has been a freelance writer and content creator for five years, working in both the English and Portuguese languages for various platforms, including WGTC.