What are the allegations against Neil Gaiman?

Content warning: this article discusses sexual assault

Neil Gaiman, a globally renowned writer known for his fantasy stories, is facing some serious sexual accusations that have rocked his extensive fanbase.

Gaiman is famed for his fantasy and horror writing across comic books and novels, with American Gods and Coraline being adapted into hit TV shows and movies. His most iconic work remains The Sandman, a rare comic with true literary depth which was recently adapted into an excellent Netflix show with a second season coming soon.

However, this storied career is now overshadowed by some grave accusations, as Gaiman has been accused by two women of sexual assault, which has led to a police complaint in New Zealand.

The disturbing allegations against Neil Gaiman

As reported by Tortoise Media, the first accuser, a young woman named Scarlett, alleges an incident that took place in Feb. 2022. Scarlett alleges that on her first day at Gaiman’s home in New Zealand, what she expected to be a standard day caring for his child quickly devolved into a distressing and non-consensual sexual encounter. She claims that Gaiman initiated physical contact by cuddling, an action she did not consent to, which escalated to more severe and degrading acts. Gaiman acknowledges the events but insists it was consensual. Scarlett’s account is reportedly backed by messages and testimonies from friends.

The second accuser, referred to as K, met Gaiman at a book signing in 2003. This initial encounter, filled with admiration and the innocence of fandom, reportedly led to a relationship two years later when K was 20. Sshe describes a relationship characterized by sexual encounters that she felt were forced upon her, including one particularly violent incident. Gaiman has responded to these claims by suggesting that K’s allegations arise from her regret after the relationship ended. He also disputed Scarlett’s claims by attributing them to a medical condition related to false memories — a claim that reportedly appears unsupported by any medical records.

So far, Gaiman has responded to the allegations with a firm denial. He also pointed out that when a complaint was made in 2022, he proactively offered his cooperation to the New Zealand police, suggesting that Gaiman believes that his eagerness to assist reflects the baselessness of the accusations. However, the police’s stance differs.

They have noted the logistical challenges in the investigation, citing difficulties in contacting key individuals and the geographical spread of all parties involved. This means the investigation is still going on. In the meantime, fans are left to navigate the complicated terrain of separating art from the artist.

If you or a loved one are a survivor of sexual assault, you can call the National Sexual Assault Hotline (1-800-656-4673) or visit its website for confidential support.