Senator Lisa Murkowski, a Republican from Alaska, joined Democrats to voice concerns about the nomination of Dennis Kirk to lead the Interior Department’s nonpartisan watchdog office, The Hill reports. The confirmation hearing held by the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee highlighted significant tension regarding Kirk’s background and his ability to remain impartial while serving in a role intended to oversee the executive branch.
Kirk faces scrutiny because of his history in political positions, including his time at the White House Office of Personnel Management during the first term of President Trump. His involvement as a co-author of a chapter in Project 2025, which is a blueprint for a conservative administration produced by the Heritage Foundation, has also added to the controversy surrounding his potential appointment.
During the hearing, Murkowski brought up objections from Mark Greenblatt, the previous inspector general who was fired by President Trump last year. Murkowski quoted Greenblatt directly during her questioning of the nominee. She told Kirk, “The former inspector general, Mark Greenblatt … I just want you to respond to a comment that he has made about your nomination. This is your opportunity to tell us why you think you should deserve to get this job.”
With Democrats retaking the majority in January, Republicans have a limited window to advance the nomination
Murkowski then shared the critique from Greenblatt, which states, “Inspectors general must be able to investigate the administration that appointed them without fear or favor. Mr. Kirk’s political background and close ties to this administration make it impossible for him to credibly meet that fundamental test.”
Murkowski emphasized that the role of an inspector general requires an unbiased view and the ability to act without tipping the scale due to political favor. Kirk responded to these concerns by promising that he would perform independent oversight if he is confirmed. He stated, “If confirmed, I guarantee you that I will implement absolutely independent oversight, excellence, integrity, and accountability.” He further committed to performing audits and investigations while providing reports directly to Congress.
Democratic senators also expressed doubt during the session. Senator Mazie Hirono of Hawaii challenged Kirk on whether he could perform his duties without fear or favor. When Hirono suggested that President Trump expects loyalty and does not believe the rule of law applies to him, Kirk replied that he has never met the President and has not had such experiences.
Senator Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada questioned the nominee about his willingness to investigate potential conflicts of interest within the Interior Department regarding tech investments and data centers on public lands. When she asked if he would commit to an investigation, Kirk declined to give a definitive yes. He stated that he would be responsive to those issues in good faith, noting he is a person focused on budget transformation and taxpayer dollars. Cortez Masto characterized his response as a “nonanswer.”
The confirmation process for Kirk remains uncertain, as he faces another hearing on Thursday, January 16, before the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee. Greenblatt noted that the back-to-back hearings look like a move to push the nomination through quickly.
Following the hearing, Greenblatt described the performance of the nominee as uninspiring. He stated, “He mouthed the words of independence, but it seemed like an afterthought more than a core commitment.”
Published: Nov 19, 2026 08:30 am