Why can't an 11-year-old be charged in California?
Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.
Images courtesy of TyliJura on Pixabay.

California mom says her Black son, 14, was called a ‘monkey’ and slapped by an 11-year-old at school, but the boy is too young to be charged

The boy reportedly offered a later apology.

A California mother is praising her 14-year-old son for not fighting back after an 11-year-old allegedly called him a “monkey” and slapped him during an after-school basketball game at a Los Angeles County public middle school, as reported by Atlanta Black Star. The mother, Elani Kay, said after-school program aides saw the slap.

Kay said an after-school program supervisor called her on a Thursday to report the incident. Her son, who is about six feet tall in shoes, attends a school where she said Black students make up less than 4% of enrollment. She said he confronted the younger boy, put his hand in his face, and said, “Hey, don’t ever talk like that to me again. Don’t call me that name,” before the boy allegedly slapped him and ran off.

In her original Threads post, Kay wrote that her son “tapped his cheek” and acknowledged that touching the boy wasn’t appropriate. She wrote that the other boy ran up and slapped him after her son walked away.

The officer said he handled it better than most grown men

Kay said things escalated when someone contacted the other boy’s mother, who she said yelled, cursed, made threats, and demanded to know why her son was being held accountable. School police were called, and Kay agreed to let her son speak with an officer after the dean assured her the other boy’s mother wouldn’t be present. Afterward, the officer told Kay her son had handled himself better than “90% of other grown men” would have.

Because the other student is 11, police could not pursue the case in juvenile delinquency court, according to Yahoo News. California sets 12 as the minimum age for juvenile court jurisdiction, and children under 12 can only be brought before the court if they are accused of murder or certain forcible sex offenses. School police completed a report.

The age limit doesn’t stop the school from disciplining a student. Under California Education Code Section 48900.3, students in grades four through 12 can be suspended or recommended for expulsion for certain acts of hate violence, but Kay said she does not know how the school disciplined the boy, who has since apologized to her son.

Kay said the dean was empathetic and quick to respond, telling her, “When your kids are in school, you guys are not here to protect them. So it’s our responsibility to do that.” She said the reassurance meant a lot after her own painful experiences with racial mistreatment in high school, when she felt officials didn’t protect her.

She wants schools to take slurs more seriously

Kay said her son regularly hears classmates use the N-word, and she questioned whether the dean’s regular talks with students about slurs are working. She said schools need clear consequences for racist language, adding, “If there is language that’s caught being used, then they need…whatever other consequences that they can face for it to stop.”

Kay also worries that her son’s height may lead adults to see him as older than he is. “It’s hard for these kids that, you know, are taller and bigger and adults want to look at them like they’re grown, but they’re not. They’re still children,” she said. She hopes the incident will lead parents and administrators to take a closer look at how schools address racial harassment.

Kay said she hopes the police involvement “awakens something in that family,” adding that the boy might have been arrested had he been 12. The other family’s side could not be independently verified.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
More Stories To Read
Author
Image of Fred Onyango
Fred Onyango
Fred Onyango is an entertainment journalist who primarily focuses on the intersection of entertainment, society, and politics. He has been writing about the entertainment industry for five years, covering celebrity, music, and film through the lens of their impact on society and politics. He has reported from the London Film Festival and was among the first African entertainment journalists invited to cover the Sundance Film Festival. Fun fact—Fred is also a trained pilot.