Three former teachers at a daycare in Forsyth, Georgia, have been indicted for allegedly administering medication to toddlers to induce sleep without either prescriptions or parental consent. Cathy Carlisle Stevick, Kendasja Mequia Hughley, and Shelby Ashlynn Webb face a total of 23 counts each, including reckless conduct and first-degree cruelty to children. These charges arise from incidents that occurred in March 2025 at the Caring for Kids daycare, located within Forsyth Methodist Church.
According to Law&Crime, an investigation began after a staff member reported that toddlers were being given Benadryl, an antihistamine known for causing drowsiness, during nap time. Investigators said at least three children, some as young as two, were administered the medication on two separate occasions.
Hughley was arrested in March 2025 after investigators said she applied the medication to toddlers, including children as young as two. Webb and Stevick were arrested later that month. Investigators reported that at least three children received doses on two separate occasions, with some incidents captured on surveillance video. Benadryl’s manufacturer does not recommend the medication for children under six.
The daycare’s alleged negligence goes beyond drugging children
“This teacher had apparently been doing this for a longer period of time with some children,” Reg Griffin from the Georgia Department of Early Care and Learning told WGXA. “The only idea the parents had was that when they picked up their children at the end of the day, they were extremely sluggish and not acting normal.”
However, the daycare’s alleged negligence extended beyond dosing children with medication. According to Reg Griffin, teachers “basically wrestled” young children down to a mat as they tried to return to the classroom. “When they were trying to get them back in the classroom, we saw a couple of instances where they basically wrestled them down to a mat,” he said.
In addition to the medication allegations, Hughley is accused of using physical force against multiple children, including an incident where she allegedly physically mistreated multiple toddlers by kicking, hitting, grabbing, and pulling them by their hair, per WGMT.
Shelby Webb is also charged with one count of felony first-degree cruelty to children and one misdemeanor count of simple battery, stemming from charges that she allegedly yanked a child’s arm. Cathy Stevick, the daycare’s director, will face three misdemeanor counts of failing to report child abuse for allegedly not notifying authorities about the incidents.
Under Georgia law, professionals, including school officials, are required to report suspected child neglect, abandonment, abuse, or exploitation to the appropriate authorities. The daycare was eventually closed after investigators obtained surveillance footage of the alleged offenses being committed and determined that the children were in imminent danger.
Published: Nov 19, 2026 02:30 pm