Moving to a new place is already exhausting, and finding a moving company to safely store your belongings can be expensive. Hiring movers should make the process easier, and New York-based moving and storage company Piece of Cake claims to take the stress out of the experience. However, one content creator is raising concerns about this well-known online moving company, alleging it only makes the process more difficult.
New York TikToker Bayley (@type_bay) is known for warning viewers to avoid certain companies, and this time is no different. In a seven-second clip, the camera pans around before landing on one of Piece of Cake’s distinctive hot pink vans parked at a storage facility.
Bayley claims that Piece of Cake is withholding customers’ belongings unless each mover receives at least a 20% tip. “Oh, and here they are holding your stuff hostage because you didn’t pay each individual mover 20% of the move,” she writes in the text overlay. The content creator emphasizes service over tip in the caption, writing, “If the service was bad, you don’t need to tip.” She also uploaded a follow-up video of herself flipping off a moving Piece of Cake van.
Piece of Cake claims tipping is “up to clients’ discretion”
While the video does little to back up the glaring claim, viewers were still shocked upon learning about Piece of Cake’s alleged practice. “I’d call the cops because now you’ve stolen my belongings,” one viewer commented. “I would’ve sat on the top of the roof of the car,” another stated. “Yeah they would have to get a new set of tires before I let someone steal my s—-,” a third remarked.
Others have also shared their similar experiences with the alleged aggressive tipping practices. “They tried this with my mom until my brother pulled up,” one commenter shared. “This happened to me last year. They stopped unloading halfway through and demanded more money. Ended up finishing the job myself and from now on will be moving all my stuff on my own [because] I don’t need no con man to do something I can do myself,” a second recalled. Piece of Cake has not responded to the allegations or addressed them in any way as of publication.
According to Piece of Cake’s website, tipping is up to the customer. “While tipping is completely up to clients’ discretion, if you are fully satisfied with your moving crew’s performance, we recommend tipping in the amount of 15-20% of a move total,” per its FAQ. The company also provides more specific guidance: for local moves, they recommend tipping 15-20% of the total cost, while for long-distance moves, they suggest 10-15% of the total cost. NerdWallet also suggests that tipping movers is customary, as a 2025 Consumer Affairs survey found that only 3% of people who have moved in the past three years report never tipping their movers.
Published: Nov 19, 2026 05:30 pm