The Pentagon threatens the Vatican with a 14th-century power play, and JD Vance claims he had no idea about it

Vice President JD Vance was asked about a report claiming the Pentagon threatened the Vatican with military force. Vance said he had no prior knowledge of it. The report outlined a serious escalation in tensions between President Donald Trump‘s White House and Pope Leo XIV.

According to the report, U.S. officials complained about a speech by Pope Leo XIV, after he took indirect shots at President Trump. They reportedly invited Cardinal Christophe Pierre, the Holy See’s ambassador to the U.S., to the Pentagon, where one official referenced the Avignon Papacy of the 14th century, a period when the French Crown dictated terms to the Catholic Church. 

Independent reporter Christopher Hale later clarified that the Vatican interpreted this as a direct threat. According to Mediaite, when asked about the report in Budapest, Vance initially drew a blank on who Cardinal Pierre was. Once informed, he said, “Oh, OK, OK, I’ve met him before,” and added, “I’ve never seen this reporting. I’d like to actually talk to Cardinal Christophe Pierre, and frankly, to our people, to figure out what actually happened.” 

The Trump administration’s strained relationship with the Vatican has been building for months

Vance also said, “I think it’s always a bad idea to offer an opinion on stories that are unconfirmed and uncorroborated, so I’m not going to do that.” Tensions between the Trump administration and the Vatican had apparently been building for some time. 

The administration had reportedly hoped that the first American Pope would support its agenda and provide moral backing for its policies. However, Pope Leo XIV’s public statements have consistently gone against the White House’s preferred positions.

On Easter Sunday, Pope Leo XIV urged world leaders to choose peace and lay down their weapons. He specifically called for an end to “the desire to dominate others” and condemned “the imperialist occupation of the world.” He also warned that God rejects the prayers “of those who wage war.”

These remarks were seen by many as a direct critique of U.S. foreign policy, particularly given the ongoing Iran war, where reports suggest hundreds of U.S. troops have been killed or injured as fighting continues.

According to The Free Press, the private tensions reportedly boiled over in January, when senior U.S. defense officials summoned the top Vatican diplomat to the Pentagon. Vatican officials, speaking on condition of anonymity, described that meeting as a “bitter lecture.” They said U.S. officials warned that the United States has the military power to do whatever it wants and that the Church should align itself with Washington.

The Catholic Church, despite its own challenges, is considered one of the last global institutions that still holds genuine moral authority. The Holy See’s credibility is something even a superpower like the United States seeks, and the administration understood that Pope Leo’s backing, or even his silence on key issues, could provide a moral legitimacy that military or economic power alone cannot.

This explains why the administration was reportedly frustrated by Pope Leo XIV’s independent stance and his repeated calls for peace. When he speaks out against “imperialist occupation” or the “desire to dominate others,” it challenges the moral image any administration wants to project, especially during ongoing conflicts like the Iran war.

The alleged threat, if true, points to the administration’s desire to silence dissenting moral voices on the global stage. This is especially relevant as the Pentagon is reportedly planning weeks of ground operations in Iran, a significant escalation in the conflict.