Family of 17 sat down for a LongHorn Steakhouse dinner. All was good – until they checked their bank statements at home that night

LongHorn Steakhouse has fully refunded a family of 17 after they found extra charges on their bank statements following a dinner at the restaurant. The issue came to light after TikTok creator Jennifer (@exclusivelyjen) shared her experience, claiming her family was “scammed” by a server during their meal. The restaurant later confirmed that a server had added an unauthorized to-go order to one of their tabs.

She explained that all 17 family members sat down for dinner, and everything seemed normal throughout the meal. They paid their bills and went home without suspecting anything. It was only later that night, when they checked their bank accounts, that they noticed the amounts charged were higher than what was written on their receipts. According to Brobible, the family had split their bill across five separate checks.

Jennifer claimed that the server had added an extra $20 tip to three of those five checks, totaling $60 in unauthorized charges. She also wondered if the server was doing this regularly. “Now I’m thinking maybe she’s doing it to every person that night,” she said. “Maybe she’s doing it every time that she works.” She left a negative Google review and called on LongHorn Steakhouse to “fix it” and “hire better servers” who aren’t “stealing from their customers.”

LongHorn Steakhouse got rid of automatic gratuity years ago, and there’s a clear tax reason behind it

After the video went viral on TikTok, one person wrote, “even if you pay and tip separately all checks will have a auto gratuity at 18%.” Another suggested, “You can go up there and check. They can look at the tip put in and then look at the tip on the receipt.” Bank-related issues going viral are not uncommon; in one recent case, a single cent overdraft triggered a massive viral controversy online.

However, LongHorn Steakhouse, like many large restaurant chains, stopped using automatic gratuity years ago. This happened after an IRS rule update in 2013, which changed how automatic tips were classified. Before the update, tips were left for employees to report on their own tax returns. After the update, any automatic tip added to a bill was treated as a service charge, meaning it was classified as regular wages paid by the restaurant.

This meant restaurants had to withhold mandatory payroll taxes on those amounts, specifically 7.65% of gross pay, with 6.2% going to Social Security and 1.45% to Medicare. Darden Restaurants, the parent company that owns LongHorn Steakhouse, Olive Garden, and Red Lobster, was among the first to eliminate automatic gratuity after this rule change. 

Texas Roadhouse also announced plans to phase out their 18% automatic gratuity around the same time. According to Kaufman Financial Services, the removal of automatic gratuity directly affected servers. Financial advisor Douglas Kaufman noted at the time that the automatic 18% gratuity for large parties helped ensure servers were fairly compensated for handling big, often demanding tables.

Following advice from commenters, Jennifer called the restaurant directly. The restaurant told her that the server “didn’t turn in any of the receipts that night.” When staff pulled up the orders on their point-of-sale system, they found that on one of Jennifer’s sister’s tabs, the server had charged an extra $40 for a to-go order that was never placed.

LongHorn Steakhouse fully refunded everyone in the family who had been overcharged. Keeping a close eye on your account balance can make all the difference in situations like this, much like a woman who checked her bank balance after someone called her broke at Walmart, proving that staying on top of your finances matters.