‘Bloody-handed’ Wisconsin man caught driving a stolen Chevy Caprice. He’s accused of a fatal stabbing, triggered by finger-pointing

On Jan. 21, 2026, Indiana police arrested 34-year-old Jacob Sanders of Mauston, Wisconsin, after a routine traffic stop led to the discovery of blood on his hands and inside a stolen 1989 Chevy Caprice later tied to a homicide investigation in Wisconsin, authorities said.

Police in Indiana stopped Sanders because he was not wearing a seatbelt and made an abrupt turn without signaling, according to local reports. During the stop, deputies with the Vigo County Sheriff’s Office observed what they described as blood on Sanders’ hands and on the steering wheel of the vehicle. Sanders told the deputy the car belonged to his father. Sanders admitted he did not have his father’s permission to be driving it.

Beyond the blood on his hands and steering wheel, deputies also observed blood on the driver’s seat and a white, bleach-like stain on Jacob’s coat, suggesting an attempt to clean up.

Cops requested a welfare check on Sanders’ dad

Suspicious of the circumstances, the deputy contacted Wisconsin authorities, requesting a welfare check on Sanders’ father, Michael Sanders, who lived in Mauston. Wisconsin police found 73-year-old Michael Sanders dead inside his motel room, with multiple stab wounds and severe injuries consistent with a violent attack, according to court documents obtained by Law & Crime.

The probable cause affidavit, obtained by Law & Crime, indicates that officers found the elder Sanders’ body on a bed with numerous stab wounds, including defensive injuries to his hands and near-severed digits on his left index finger and thumb. Investigators later found a blood-stained Karambit-style knife in Jacob’s motel room, a curved-bladed weapon often associated with combat or hunting knives.

Investigators told police the two had a strained relationship, and that Jacob became upset when his father would point his finger at him, a behavior the suspect described as something that “triggered” him emotionally.

Sanders’ new charges

Police initially booked Sanders on charges related to the suspected stolen car. Wisconsin authorities have since issued a warrant for Sanders’ arrest for first-degree intentional homicide and related charges. He is currently being held at the Vigo County Jail with extradition proceedings pending to Wisconsin.

An autopsy conducted at a University of Wisconsin Health facility assisted in determining the circumstances of the fatal attack, though Wisconsin police have not released the full autopsy report at this time.

If extradited, Sanders is expected to appear in Juneau County Circuit Court on the homicide charge. First-degree intentional homicide is the most serious felony in Wisconsin and carries the potential for a life sentence if convicted. Local prosecutors will determine whether additional charges — such as use of a weapon during a violent crime or other enhancements — are appropriate based on evidence collected at the scene and in follow-up interviews.

At this stage, police have not indicated any danger to the public, and investigators are continuing to gather evidence to support the state’s case. Community members with information relevant to the case are being urged to contact the Juneau County Sheriff’s Office or local law enforcement.