Fate of monster who fed 5yo girl to alligators in Florida Everglades to be decided once and for all

A Florida man convicted of murdering a five-year-old girl back in 1998 is currently facing his resentencing trial this month. Harrel Braddy, 76, kidnapped Shandelle Maycock and her daughter Quatisha ‘Candy’ Maycock on November 7th 1998 before throwing the young girl into the Florida Everglades and leaving her to be eaten by the alligators.

A couple of days after the kidnapping, Candy’s body was found by a fisherman in the Everglades in an area infested with alligators. She was missing an arm and was covered in bite marks from fish and alligators.

What happened to Candy and her mother?

Shandelle Maycock would later tell detectives that she had met Harrel Braddy and his wife through a local church group and he had been helping the single mother out. According to an article from the Daily Mail, Braddy overstayed his welcome one night and after Shandelle asked him to leave he became enraged and began beating her before forcing her and Candy into his car.

At one point Shandelle tried to leap out of the car with her daughter but Braddy allegedly increased his speed when she opened the car door, causing them both to be thrown from the vehicle. He then came back and threw Shandelle in the trunk before continuing his drive.

Eventually he pulled over and took Shandelle from the trunk before choking her until she was unconscious. State Prosecutor Abbe Rifkin stated that Braddy left her there believing he had killed her. He then drove on with Candy to the Everglades where he threw her in and left the five-year-old, who was still wearing her pajamas, to be eaten by the alligators.

Harrel Braddy’s sentencing

Braddy had been released from prison a little over a year prior. He had served only 12 years of a 30 year sentence for charges including attempted murder, robbery, kidnapping and burglary, according to the Florida Department of Corrections.

While he had tried to cover his tracks, Shandelle woke up the next morning and was able to get help. Braddy was convicted of first-degree murder in 2007 and was sentenced to death. However, 10 years later his sentence was reversed after the US Supreme Court found the death penalty in Florida to be unconstitutional.

The law was updated in 2023 to allow for the death penalty if the jury voted 8-4 in favor. Braddy has remained in prison since but is finally facing his re-sentencing where the death penalty is once again on the table. His trial began earlier this week and Shandelle will also be present in court.