What happened to Matthew Sturniolo, and did his triplet brother murder him?

The Sturniolo family has seen its fair share of tragedy if some TikTok posts are to be believed.

Perhaps you’ve seen posts on TikTok commemorating the third anniversary of Matthew Sturniolo‘s death, who at least one post says was murdered by his brother, Nicholas Sturniolo. Nicholas was then sentenced to life in prison. Curiously, though, as of Spring 2024, Matthew was still posting on Instagram.

Recommended Videos

In case you’re not aware, the Sturniolo brothers are internet-famous triplet YouTubers and social media personalities, with millions of followers on TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram. So, was there a murder in the Sturniolo family, when according to one TikTok, post, Nicholas put rat poisoning in Matthew’s food? Or is Matthew still breathing?

Relax everybody, Matthew Sturniolo is just fine

via Sturniolo Supercuts/TikTok

Rest easy, Sturniolo fans, Matt’s fine, it was all a dark joke, as comments on one TikTok post about the purported fratricide explain. It all started when the Sturniolos shared a video seeming to show Matthew eating poisoned food and falling over dead, in what’s now known as the “poison prank.” Watch the original poison prank video, and it’s clear that it’s fake, but as these things sometimes go on the internet, it took on a life of its own helped by cuts mentioning what supposedly happened. The news still shocks fans today.

In one post’s comments, someone wrote, “[G]uys it js a joke😭💀[sic].” Meanwhile, Sturniolo Supercuts added recently, “In two months this video will be a year old and people still don’t know it’s a joke.” People continue falling for it, though, based on comments like, “I actually believed it and was searching Google about it 😭😭”

What happened to Christopher Sturniolo, is he dead?

@coquettechris

if i see one more person saying chris has been in a car accident and is un*lve oml he is fine yall please dont call paw patrol LMFAO i cant help but laugh. anyway i love matt side eyeing | the sturniolo fandom is crazy sometimes man yall will spread rumors like wildfire #mattsideeye #mattsideeyeing #mattsturniolo #matthewsturniolo #nicksturniolo #chrisstophersturniolo #chrissturniolo #new #trend #trending #real #relatable #fyp #foryou #foryoupage #sturniolos #thesturniolos #sturniolotriplets #thesturniolotriplets #carcrash #accident #current #unserious #funny #comedy @Ava🌷 @anita @kami 🐺 @Ems @faith 😇 @Amelia🌟 @✰shen✰ @𝘌𝘴𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 ✰ @❕K⃨e⃨l⃨b⃨y⃨❕ @🧡😜chris girl😜🧡 @bekah 🍂 @dropdeadinsane @Gabbie

♬ where yo swag – PE7EZS
via Coquettechrist/TikTok

Meanwhile, in spring 2024, another Sturniolo death hoax made the rounds, as rumors spread that Christopher Sturniolo died in a car accident, but that news, too, isn’t real. In one comment, someone explained,” ” … [S]omeone made a photoshop news thing that chris died and people believe it 💀[sic]” But another fan added, “[D]ude i just seen this and was SHOOK [sic].” But take a deep breath, because all three Sturniolo triplets are alive and well.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Author
Image of William Kennedy
William Kennedy
William Kennedy is a full-time freelance content writer and journalist in Eugene, OR. William covered true crime, among other topics for Grunge.com. He also writes about live music for the Eugene Weekly, where his beat also includes arts and culture, food, and current events. He lives with his wife, daughter, and two cats who all politely accommodate his obsession with Doctor Who and The New Yorker.