Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.

Homeland Season Premiere Review: “Tin Man Is Down” (Season 3, Episode 1)

Homeland has returned, and we're immediately thrown back in the deep end. The first episode of season three lags in some areas, but it manages to cram a whole lot of story, duplicity, and action (mostly offscreen) into a single hour of television. There's peaks and troughs throughout but in this, the first episode post-Breaking Bad, is it really good enough?
This article is over 11 years old and may contain outdated information

homeland0301

Recommended Videos

While we’re pondering on the definition of terrorism, we turn to Saul. Good old Saul. Paralysed by indecision both at work and home, his wife Mira is back from Mumbai and appears to have taken on the role of caregiver, helping Saul with his shoes as he gets into bed – foreshadowing potential season 3 health problems for Saul? Occurring at a pivotal moment in proceedings? Surely not. Mira pulls Saul up on his indecision when he refuses to say whether or not he wants to share a bed with her again, saying that he’s waiting for “the right answer to reveal itself” – later on, it’s difficult not to recall that scene as he’s staring at a myriad of screens revealing an epic plan of multiple assassinations across multiple continents, with only a twenty minute window to achieve it, in what sets up a hell of an ending.

It says everything about the universe of the show and our expectations as viewers that this is initially seen as an act of heroism. Although Homeland is never one to relish action or death, always presenting it as an absolute last resort (as opposed to, say, any other TV show dealing with terrorism since 9/11), there was a thrill in seeing Quinn going Metal Gear Solid on their asses, even though it quickly became tragic, then even more so, when Saul was asked to defend what was initially presented as an heroic action.

It quickly becomes clear that what we just saw might have been completely indefensible, and it is this continual playing with audience expectations that separates Homeland from the competition. No other show tackling such solid, all-American themes as the War on Terror and patriotism would ask the audience to question what it just saw, what it just watched and accepted as an acceptable act. Have we too been turned? Are we all Brody now? Do I have to dye my hair?

There’s much to love in the periphery of the Saul/Carrie hurricane, as well. The idea of Carrie confronting Saul in a nice restaurant while everybody was enjoying a nice tiramisu was an inherently funny moment to me, and the attack-dog chairman of the congressional committee – Sen. Andrew Lockhart (Tracy Letts) – was fantastic, relishing the role and really taking pleasure in watching his various victims squirming under his gaze. Hopefully he’ll become a powerful antagonist from within the force, giving them something to contend with as well as the shadowy tendrils of Al-Qaeda. And the final moments, as the realisation of what is about to happen dawns on Carrie and, by extension, the audience, are completely heartbreaking.

In fact, so much is packed into this episode that you barely realise that Brody himself doesn’t actually show up at all. It throws so much at you that you might struggle to keep up at times, and maybe just want something to cling onto amongst the lies and double-crossing, but on a technical level “Tin Man is Down” is something to admire. Hopefully this strong opening episode points to good things to come in Homeland season 3.

Welcome back!


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Author
Image of Rob Batchelor
Rob Batchelor
Male, Midlands, mid-twenties.