Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.

New Girl Review: “Thanksgiving III” (Season 3, Episode 10)

Ahh, that beautiful tradition. So entertaining, so succulent, so magical. Yes, it's that time of year again - New Girl's Thanksgiving episode! More represented in the show than any other holiday, every Thanksgiving episode has been a real treat. Who could forget "Parents," last year's Thanksgiving episode in which Joan and Bob Day (Jamie Lee Curtis and Rob Reiner, respectively) come and stay with the gang? It gave us that Nickest of Nick punchlines - "Jess! I think I'm into your mom!", and his close relationship with Bob sowed the seeds for his and Jess' future relationship, I think.
This article is over 10 years old and may contain outdated information

newgirls03e10-02

Recommended Videos

Take the scene when Nick is building the bear trap. The jokey interplay between Schmidt, Coach, and Nick is so well-written and their timing is great together – tumbling over each other a little, other times leaving slightly too long, like a normal conversation – that it really feels like we’re watching three real friends doing friendly things together. I’ve never got that impression with Winston, oddly enough. He’s not an outsider, I just never really buy that friendship as deeply as I buy Nick, Schmidt and Coach. It doesn’t feel as real t0 me.

Tellingly, presumably to let the machismo fly unabated, Winston is put with Jess and Cece when Nick separates the group into either hunters or gatherers. Men and women. Winston joins the girls and they have a separate fun adventure, one that builds nicely into the overarching theme of Nick’s masculinity. After all, it was Nick who persuaded the gang to venture into the forest in the first place and hunt their dinner.

Jess, not wanting to be seen to diminish his manhood in front of the guys any further, does her best to support him. To what lengths does she go for her man? Well, she eats a long-dead, half-rotten fresh water fish. And I say “fresh” in the loosest possible sense of the word. She does it to prove that Nick was right to bring them out here, and is capable of hunting a Thanksgiving dinner (of sorts). That he hunted the fish as it lay on its side on the surface of the water, and that Jess, Cece, and Winston gathered the vegetables from the local health food store, is neither here nor there. If anything, the pointlessness of eating the rotting fish just underscored how much she wanted Nick’s plan to work out.

When Jess eats the fish, we finally get to see Hallucinations Jess. This season has been sorely lacking in Hallucinations Jess, staying hidden away since she drank absinthe with Nick’s crazy stripper girlfriend Angie (Olivia Munn) in last season’s “Cabin.” She was still with Sam, to give you a little context. So it’s been a long time.

Jess starts hallucinating as a result of eating the fish, and escapes into the woods. Eagle-eyed viewers could probably guess how they would catch her in the end, and it did serve to tie up each group’s plotline in a neat little bow, a facet of late period New Girl that I’ve come to really appreciate. They’re getting really good at dovetailing the stories into one pleasing whole, to round the episode off nicely. They do get their Thanksgiving dinner eventually, and the episode has a nice happy ending, with Jess’ stated wish – that she just wants the group to be together, eating, and happy – coming true. This is a group vaguely reunited for now, and hopefully for at least a couple of episodes to come. I’m glad.

Random Robservations:

  • “What are you trying to catch, a refrigerator?” was so perfectly pitched, timed, and delivered, that it gave me the biggest laugh of any line this season. A great joke that works on two or three different levels.
  • Schmidt guiding Coach in the ways of Cece is really sweet. They’re warming to each other.
  • I’d like Hallucinations Jess to become a recurring character, please.

Next week’s New Girl is the last one this year, so stay tuned!


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Author
Image of Rob Batchelor
Rob Batchelor
Male, Midlands, mid-twenties.