Rachel Goodle
Oak Creek Police Department

Who is the Oak Creek High School teacher accused of having a sexual relationship with a student?

Other students said they saw them "on a date."

This article mentions child sex abuse. Please read with caution.

Recommended Videos

A teacher and student caught alone in a room; rumors that student “cheated” with a teacher; that same student and teacher and student together at a high school basketball game, leading some to think they were on a date. These details were revealed in the personnel file of Rachel Goodle.

According to Fox6now.com, in 2022, Rachel Goodle, in her early 20s, was a ninth-grade English teacher at Oak Creek High School in Wisconsin when other students at the school reported that Goodle had sexually abused a male student at the school. Fox6Now.com obtained Goodle’s personnel file amid an ongoing investigation as of this report. TMJ4.com says the student, unnamed in the press, was younger than 16 years old.

The video footage

Fox 6 News Milwaukee/YouTube

The primary evidence against Goodle is surveillance footage showing her leaving the school after classes, and returning later wearing a dress. Goodle then met the student in her classroom. They reportedly remained for more than an hour behind closed doors. Janitorial staff encountered them, and cleaning staff later said they assumed Goodle and the boy were mother and son.

At the same time, rumors were rampant at Oak Creek High School that something was going on between Goodle and the boy, including one instance when they sat together at a JV basketball game as if they were on a date. When questioned, the student denied anything sexual happened.

The school district tried to handle it on its own

In Dec. 2022, the Oak Creek-Franklin Joint School District investigated the alleged relationship between Rachel Goodle and the student. At first, Goodle denied she was alone with the student, despite the video evidence to the contrary, but because Goodle, the student, and the student’s family denied anything sexual happened, she was only suspended. Goodle challenged the terms of the punishment.

The matter seemed settled until an Oak Creek High School resource officer heard the student tell another student he “cheated” with a teacher. After that point, Oak Creek police got involved, and in May 2023, the boy finally admitted what happened.

Goodle’s charges

In June 2023, Goodle was arrested and charged with second-degree sexual assault of a child, and sex assault of a student by school staff. She pleaded not guilty. According to Detective Zach Case, Goodle said she and the boy were “in a somewhat friendly relationship.”

According to a statement from the victim’s attorney, this is the second time in less than six years that a teacher at Oak Creek High School was accused of sexual abuse on school grounds and called for an investigation of school leadership. Goodle’s trial is set to begin in April 2024. If convicted. Goodle could spend more than 40 years in prison.

If you know someone suffering from sexual violence, contact RAINN or the National Sexual Abuse Telephone Hotline at 1-800-656-4673.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more
related content
Read Article Who is the Brazilian ‘Baby Reindeer’ stalker who became obsessed with her doctor after he saved her life?
Kawara Welch
Read Article Pantera’s Dimebag Darrell was one of the greatest guitarists of all time. So what happened on the night he was murdered on stage?
Gutchie Kojima/Shinko Music/Getty Images) Pantera, photo shoot in Tokyo during their First Japan tour 2006, Japan, July 1992. Dimebag Darrell (guitar). (Photo by Gutchie Kojima/Shinko Music/Getty Images)
Read Article Did Boeing kill whistleblower John Barnett? The crime scene evidence, explained
John Barnett and crime scene evidence
Read Article Is there a Netflix release date for 50 Cent’s Diddy docu-series?
Photo montage of rappers 50 Cent and Diddy.
Read Article Ronnie Joe Kirk disappeared in 1970. How did his skeleton end up in a music store chimney?
Ronne Joe Kirk "Chimeny Doe" evidence
Related Content
Read Article Who is the Brazilian ‘Baby Reindeer’ stalker who became obsessed with her doctor after he saved her life?
Kawara Welch
Read Article Pantera’s Dimebag Darrell was one of the greatest guitarists of all time. So what happened on the night he was murdered on stage?
Gutchie Kojima/Shinko Music/Getty Images) Pantera, photo shoot in Tokyo during their First Japan tour 2006, Japan, July 1992. Dimebag Darrell (guitar). (Photo by Gutchie Kojima/Shinko Music/Getty Images)
Read Article Did Boeing kill whistleblower John Barnett? The crime scene evidence, explained
John Barnett and crime scene evidence
Read Article Is there a Netflix release date for 50 Cent’s Diddy docu-series?
Photo montage of rappers 50 Cent and Diddy.
Read Article Ronnie Joe Kirk disappeared in 1970. How did his skeleton end up in a music store chimney?
Ronne Joe Kirk "Chimeny Doe" evidence
Author
William Kennedy
William Kennedy is a full-time freelance content writer and journalist in Eugene, OR. William covered true crime, among other topics for Grunge.com. He also writes about live music for the Eugene Weekly, where his beat also includes arts and culture, food, and current events. He lives with his wife, daughter, and two cats who all politely accommodate his obsession with Doctor Who and The New Yorker.