An Orlando realtor claimed that a client once told her he used to be in the mob, then later called to say someone from his past had “paid him a visit.” Karly Campbell shared the story in a TikTok video about her early days as an agent, as first highlighted by BroBible.
Campbell said she was “so desperate for a sale” as a new agent that she took on a listing for an elderly man’s dated three-bedroom home on two and a half acres. She claimed the house had bars on the windows, numerous padlocks on the doors, and a room filled with tools.
“The whole house smelled like urine, and he did not have any cats or dogs,” she claimed. Campbell then explained the man called her every other day to talk about his life and his problems, often dropping hints that he wanted a wife.
She kept noticing red flags
Campbell said she eventually learned that before the man immigrated to the U.S., he was in the mob. Then she says he mysteriously went quiet.
When he finally reached out, Campbell said he told her someone from his past had broken into his home, beaten him, tied him up, and robbed him at gunpoint. “I’m getting weirded out and the house isn’t getting any showings,” she said, adding that the home sat on the market for two months without a single showing.
Campbell said she decided to end the listing and visited the man to have him sign the termination paperwork. She claimed he showed her medical reports from a recent hospital stay and mentioned a medical implant. “I was appalled and he was like smirking when he said it,” she said.
She said she got his signature and left right away. “I blocked him and never heard from him again,” Campbell said.
Campbell admitted the asking price was too high from the start. Some listings struggle for reasons buyers never see, such as a Colorado home sold with its occupant still inside.
Several real estate agents in the comments said strange experiences come with the job, ranging from difficult clients to creepy home tours gone wrong. “As a real estate agent, I’m not the least surprised by a single word you said, and I believe you,” one viewer wrote, while another wrote, “The way it kept getting worse.”
Agent safety is a known concern in the industry. In 2023, 22% of residential Realtors said they experienced a situation that made them fear for their personal safety or the safety of their personal information, according to the National Association of Realtors, as reported by the Pennsylvania Association of Realtors. Receiving a threatening or inappropriate email, text, call, or voicemail was among the most common triggers, cited by 29% of those agents.
Published: Nov 19, 2026 11:30 am