Why was Thomas Overton executed in Florida?
Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.
Image by Andrés Ramírez on Pexels.

Pregnant Florida teacher killed after she paid for gas with a check showing her address, then 35 years later, the gas station attendant is executed

A simple gas payment put this teacher on a killer’s radar.

Florida executed Thomas Mitchell Overton on Thursday for the 1991 murders of a pregnant teacher, Key Largo and her husband. Overton, 71, was pronounced dead at 6:19 PM after a lethal injection at Florida State Prison in Raiford, the Associated Press reported.

Weeks before the killings, Susan “Missy” MacIvor paid $7.35 for gas at a local Amoco station with a personal check that showed her home address. Overton was working there at the time, and Missy had told her sister that a gas station attendant there gave her the creeps.

The execution was Florida’s 20th of the year, breaking the state record of 19 set in 2025. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed Overton’s death warrant last month.

It took five years to find a suspect

Missy was 29 and taught third grade at Key Largo Elementary School. She was pregnant with her first child, a boy she and her husband, Michael, planned to name Kyle Patrick.

Colleagues contacted neighbors when Missy failed to show up for work, which led to the discovery of the couple’s bodies inside their home near Tavernaero Airport. Court records indicate the phone lines had been cut and both victims had been strangled. Michael had also been beaten, and Missy had been sexually assaulted.

Detectives went five years without a suspect until the cold case was solved in 1996, when investigators matched DNA from the crime scene to Overton. He was a career burglar living in Tavernier and was in jail on an unrelated burglary charge at the time.

A jury convicted Overton of both murders in 1999 and recommended death sentences by votes of 9 to 3 for Missy’s killing and 8 to 4 for Michael’s. He later received a life sentence for a 1996 burglary to make sure he would stay in prison if the murder convictions were overturned.

Overton maintained his innocence until the end. In his final statement, he said, “I’ve never sexually assaulted anyone. I never killed anyone. I didn’t kill the MacIvors.”

Monroe County Sheriff Rick Ramsay responded to the crime scene as a young patrol officer and called it one of the most heinous cases of his 40-year career. “I will never forget and am thankful for a final end to this 35-year case,” he said.

Monroe State Attorney Dennis Ward called Overton a cold-blooded killer and noted that the execution ended more than three decades of appeals. “Justice has been served, but no execution can undo the suffering he caused or return three innocent lives. Michael, Missy, and Kyle Patrick MacIvor will never be forgotten,” Ward said.

Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty opposed the execution. The group acknowledged the brutality of the crimes but pointed out that Overton was a military veteran and a survivor of abuse at the Dozier School for Boys. Florida has two more executions planned for December.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
More Stories To Read
Author
Image of Sameera Sohail
Sameera Sohail
Sameera Sohail is a writer at We Got This Covered. Before joining the site, she worked on websites posts and social media posts for Dilwado.com, along with promotional copy for a local business, and she spent time in sales and customer support at Concentrix. She's studying for a BCom at Ranchi University.