A Wisconsin man has been charged by prosecutors in connection with the death of his wife in October 2024. The man initially claimed that he had slipped while carrying his wife up the stairs, resulting in her death; however, investigators alleged that he had planned to murder his wife.
On October 14, 2024, around 10:30 p.m., officers were called for a welfare check at a home near South 95th and West Dakota in West Allis. When officers arrived at the scene, investigators said that Benjamin Carpenter told them that he and his wife, Erica, had been doing laundry in the basement when she collapsed and hit her head, “mildly hard,” according to a criminal complaint obtained by TMJ4.
Afterwards, he claimed that he had tried to carry his wife up the stairs but had slipped, which caused them both to fall down the stairs. Carpenter claimed that his wife had fallen and hit her head on a cinder block at the bottom of the stairs. She was subsequently taken to hospital but later died from her injuries.
Carpenter’s alleged affair and incriminating phone records
Benjamin was asked about his relationship with Erica, to which he allegedly said, “It’s good.” However, according to the court documents, he allegedly admitted to having an affair with another woman and claimed he had planned to ask for a divorce from his wife the weekend she died.
He also allegedly contacted his insurance numerous times to ask when his wife’s $300,000 life insurance policy would be paid out. He had reportedly told police that he was not aware his wife had a life insurance policy.
When investigators checked his phone records, they allegedly discovered a text conversation in which Erica had accused him of tampering with her water. In the text, his wife said: “There’s been powdery s**t in it at least twice now.”
Carpenter’s search history from the same day as the text conversation was also recovered, with him allegedly searching the terms “losing someone,” “watching someone you love die,” and “Death of a Loved One: Quotes, Poems, and Resources is with…”
Investigators alleged that in a deleted conversation between Benjamin and Erica a week before her death, she had asked him to research a sleep aid for her. Erica’s toxicology report found both doxylamine, a medication used for insomnia, and hydrocodone, a strong pain medication.
Carpenter was arrested on November 17 and made an initial appearance in court on Wednesday, where a judge set his bond at $500,000. His preliminary hearing is scheduled for December 8.
Published: Nov 20, 2026 03:30 pm