Susan Smith, who was convicted of drowning her two young sons, was sentenced to life in prison in 1995. Now, more than 30 years later, her application for parole was unanimously denied for a second time on Thursday morning. Her first application was unanimously rejected by the South Carolina parole board in 2024, as per the Associated Press.
Smith and her team appeared through video call. Her defense team alleged that her childhood experiences shaped her decisions as an adult, citing the suicide of her father and a sexual relationship with her step-father that began in her adolescence and continued during her incarceration. Her doctor, Jessie Hill, a forensic psychiatrist, stated that she displayed signs of borderline personality disorder.
“I know that what I did to Michael and Alex was horrible,” said Smith. “They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die… I’m really, really sorry for that. I would go back and change all of that if I could. I am not the same person I was 32 years ago. I have changed.” Smith added, “If released, I want to live a life to please God and to honor the memory of Michael and Alex. I just want to give back and help other people.”
She had two affairs in prison
On October 25, 1994, Smith, then 23, told police that an African American man had approached her at a traffic light and stolen her burgundy Mazda Protégé at gunpoint with her two sons, Michael and Alex, inside. The alleged kidnapping drew national attention, with Smith and her estranged husband, David, appearing on television to plead for their children’s safe return.
However, investigators were suspicious of her account, and the search continued. On November 3, a day after her televised plea, Smith confessed to investigators at a local church that she had strapped her sons into the backseat before pushing the car into John D. Long Lake. Michael was only 3 years old, while Alex was just 14 months old.
Prosecutors alleged that Smith was motivated by her affair with Tom Findlay, whose father ran the Cosno textile mill where Smith worked as a secretary. Findley broke off the affair with a letter that expressed his desire to not have children. Smith and her attorneys refuted these claims and argued that she was suffering from mental health issues.
“The thing that hurts me the most is that people think I hurt my children in order to be with a man. That is so far from the truth,” Smith told The State in 2015. “I was a good mother and I loved my boys. There was no motive as it was not even a planned event. I was not in my right mind.”
A 2017 Time article reported that Smith faced numerous offenses in jail. She was caught possessing narcotics and marijuana, had self-harmed, and had affairs with Houston Cagle, a prison guard, and prison captain Alfred Rowe. Both men pleaded guilty. Cagle served a 3-month prison sentence, while Rowe received five years probation.
Smith’s ex-husband, David, attended the hearing with his wife, Tiffany, along with family members and the officers assigned to the case. He appeared before the parole board in tears, with a photo of his sons pinned on his chest.
“It’s been 32 years since I had to bury Michael and Alex. I know that to some of you, 32 years is a long time. But for me, it’s yesterday,” said David Smith. “She took away one of the greatest gifts that God gave in this life. She did that deliberately.”
Published: Nov 19, 2026 06:45 pm