Stephen A. Smith faced criticism after his interview with President Trump last week on the Straight Shooter podcast. Trump, who The Hill points out has previously labeled Smith an “arrogant fool” and “low IQ,” discussed his administration’s record with Black Americans and stated, “The Black community is the biggest beneficiary of what I’ve done.”
On Tuesday, Smith returned to the same podcast to explain his approach. He said he deliberately chose to let the president finish his points rather than interrupt with challenges at every turn so listeners could hear the full case Trump wanted to make.
The setting itself played a role in that decision, Smith indicated. The conversation took place inside the White House, in the Roosevelt Room, with the president of the United States.
Smith details the factors that shaped how he conducted the interview
Smith described weighing his options in real time. “Do I challenge him with the litany of questions that I had, that I wanted to address?” he asked. “Do I let people hear what that list is, or do I interrupt him?”
He concluded that Black listeners should hear the president’s own account of what he believes he has accomplished. “I decided, without trying to let him go on forever, Black folks needed to hear what he believes he has done for our community. And that’s why I let it go, at least to some degree,” Smith said.
He also pointed to Trump’s style of answering questions. Smith called the president a master at filibustering who “doesn’t hesitate to embellish,” adding that constant pushback risked turning the session into an unproductive exchange. Smith has also clashed with the president before, as when he fired back at Trump’s IQ remark.
Critics had expected a more confrontational tone, Smith acknowledged. “You had a lot of people that felt that I should have pushed back more. And I won’t say any names, but particularly people that have been in this industry before, that should understand by now what comes with an interview like that,” he said.
Some of that reaction, in his view, prioritized the appearance of tough questioning over the content of the exchange. “You want to engage in looking the part, and looking like you’re pushing back, not recognizing the fact it’s the President of the United States, you’re inside the White House in the Roosevelt Room, and in a nanosecond he could have just got up and walked out,” Smith stated. Trump has done that before, when he walked out when challenged on election claims.
After the interview, Smith reviewed several of the claims that had been made. On the idea that Black Americans benefited more than any other group, he said, “Now, obviously that’s unverifiable. It’s his opinion.” He noted that the Black unemployment rate stood at 6.6 percent in October, higher than the 6.2 percent figure from January 2025 when Trump took office again. “And that number alone can’t prove who benefited most,” Smith added.
Published: Nov 18, 2026 06:30 am