Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.
Screenshots of a man wearing a baseball cap and talking in front of fried calamari
Screengrabs via TikTok/@bobbydotube

‘Don’t you dare eat that’: Something fishy goes down when Olive Garden server denies one customer their calamari

What happened to "when you're here, you're family?"

From the fact that you can eat as many breadsticks as you want to the Fettuccine Alfredo, chances are you’ve enjoyed a meal (or two… or 100) at an Olive Garden. But have you ever heard of a customer ordering a dish and then being told that they can’t actually eat it?

Recommended Videos

The answer is probably no, because a typical restaurant experience tends to mean ordering, receiving the food, eating it, paying the bill, and going home. But TikTok user @bobbydotube had a unique experience at one of this famous chain’s locations.

Bobby and his family were ready for a nice evening when he ordered fried calamari with marinara sauce and chicken parm, but without the parm, just the chicken, and rigatoni with sauce. When the server asked if he has a dairy allergy, he said he has GERD. Bobby was squeezing lemon over the delicious-looking calamari when the manager rushed over, grabbed it, and said: “Don’t you dare eat that!”

Why? Because the calamari and mozzarella sticks were made in the same fryer, which would have it was contaminated with dairy. When he said “I’m on that sensitive, it’s okay,” the manager said they couldn’t let him have it. Bobby wasn’t allowed to have his chicken, either!

@bobbydotube

#greenscreen took my family to the Olive Garden, and after I let the waiter aware that I had a dairy allergy, the manager took away the calamari and told me I could not have the chicken cutlet that I wanted for dinner so being extremely upset, I asked her so what in the world am I supposed to eat? and she bring me this! @Olive Garden #olivegarden #familydinner #dairyfree #funnyvideo #italianfood

♬ original sound – Bobby DoTube

Did Bobby and his family leave and find somewhere else to eat? Did he go hungry the whole night? Actually, it all worked out in the end. The manager instead brought over a steak with rigatoni and meat sauce. As Bobby explained, “I should be mad right now because it’s my body,” but the food was so good. As he said, “sometimes mistakes turn out to be the best meal you ever had.”

While this might seem pretty extreme, several people shared in the comments that Olive Garden wants to be careful in case someone gets sick. One TikTok user said they work in the kitchen at a location and “we take allergies very seriously bc we don’t want a case.”

Has anyone ever sued a restaurant because of a food allergy? In 2023, a woman in Winnipeg named Gabrielle Lien Ho sued Canadian coffee chain Tim Horton’s because she said that after she placed an online order for tea with almond milk because she can’t eat dairy, and she was given cream. She got so sick that it affected her heart and she had to go to the hospital. After hearing this story, it’s definitely a good thing that Olive Garden is careful, although there is a conversation to be had about the difference between someone who suffers from GERD and someone who can’t eat anything that has come close to dairy. According to The Mayo Clinic, if you struggle with GERD, you have acid reflux regularly. Your chest can hurt and you can get heartburn.

As someone with gluten and dairy allergies (it’s a lot of fun), I totally sympathize with Bobby. Since I don’t have celiac disease, I’m not as affected by cross-contamination, and I can eat French fries that are cooked in the same fryer as food with gluten. But there are times when servers want to double check if I can eat what I’ve just ordered. While I appreciate the concern, I agree with Bobby that sometimes you just want to make your own decisions and eat your fried calamari in peace. But I also wouldn’t complain if someone brought me a steak, either.

Hot Items On Amazon This Week


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Author
Image of Aya Tsintziras
Aya Tsintziras
Aya Tsintziras is a freelance writer at We've Got This Covered who has been writing about pop culture since 2014. She has a Masters of Journalism from Toronto Metropolitan University and enjoys writing about TV dramas, horror movies, and celebrities. When not working, she's reading a thriller novel, catching up on The Real Housewives, and spending time with friends and family.