gladiator
via DreamWorks

The Oscar-winning epic that kicked off a short-lived cinematic craze battles back against the haters

A flash in the pan or a genuine trailblazer?

On the surface, you’d expect a smash hit movie that earned $460 million at the box office before going on to win five Academy Awards from 12 nominations (including Best Picture and Best Actor) as an indisputably adored all-time great, but there’s been some negativity thrown in the direction of Ridley Scott’s Gladiator.

Recommended Videos

As Hollywood tends to do, the various studios around town saw that a blockbuster historical epic had won critical and commercial acclaim, so it was decided that everybody would throw their hats into the ring, too. As a result, we ended up with the likes of Wolfgang Petersen’s Troy, Antoine Fuqua’s King Arthur, Tom Cruise’s The Last Samurai, Paul W.S. Anderson’s Pompeii, Neil Marshall’s Centurion, Kevin Macdonald’s The Eagle, Zack Snyder’s 300, Oliver Stone’s Alexander, John Lee Hancock’s The Alamo, and even Scott’s own Kingdom of Heaven, Robin Hood, and Exodus: Gods and Kings.

gladiator

The consistency was all over the place to put it lightly, but regardless of how you feel about Gladiator, nobody can deny that it served as one of the most influential films to arrive at the turn of the millennium. Basically, what The Matrix did for leather-clad sci-fi and action flicks, Russell Crowe’s Maximus Decimus Meridius did for sweeping tales of blood and battle.

And yet, a Reddit thread has ignited a firestorm of opposing opinions after it was suggested that Gladiator isn’t just overrated, but not every good. Each to their own, we suppose, but at the very least the technical wizardry and impeccably-staged action sequences can’t come under any sort of justifiable fire.

Is Gladiator a worthy Oscar-winner, a flash in the pan, or simply a bad movie that landed at the exact right time? Based on the ongoing conversation, mileage most definitely varies depending on who you ask.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
related content
Read Article The ghost of a trilogy that butchered a winning franchise and stole its star’s lifeline is churning dollars on streaming
Argylle Apple TV Plus
Argylle Apple TV Plus
Argylle Apple TV Plus
Read Article ‘This might bite me in the butt’: Pixar boss ‘bothered’ by Disney’s main mantra, shoots down a future of even considering it
Toy Story
Toy Story
Toy Story
Read Article ‘It’s hilarious how sad this is’: Star Wars ‘The Acolyte’ finds its savior in a 2008 film as it shields the Disney creation from a burning fire
Amandla Stenberg as Mae in 'The Acolyte'
Amandla Stenberg as Mae in 'The Acolyte'
Amandla Stenberg as Mae in 'The Acolyte'
Read Article Is DCU’s new ‘Blue Beetle’ animated series a sequel to the film, or a spin-off?
Blue Beetle
Blue Beetle
Blue Beetle
Read Article Review: ‘Inside Out 2’ is, like a teenager, noticeably awkward and very deserving of love
3.5 stars
Related Content
Read Article The ghost of a trilogy that butchered a winning franchise and stole its star’s lifeline is churning dollars on streaming
Argylle Apple TV Plus
Read Article ‘This might bite me in the butt’: Pixar boss ‘bothered’ by Disney’s main mantra, shoots down a future of even considering it
Toy Story
Read Article ‘It’s hilarious how sad this is’: Star Wars ‘The Acolyte’ finds its savior in a 2008 film as it shields the Disney creation from a burning fire
Amandla Stenberg as Mae in 'The Acolyte'
Read Article Is DCU’s new ‘Blue Beetle’ animated series a sequel to the film, or a spin-off?
Blue Beetle
Read Article Review: ‘Inside Out 2’ is, like a teenager, noticeably awkward and very deserving of love
3.5 stars
Author
Scott Campbell
News, reviews, interviews. To paraphrase Keanu Reeves; Words. Lots of words.