Joseph Gerard Cancellare was arrested on November 13 after authorities accused him of sending a greeting card covered in peanut butter to a woman with a severe allergy, CTV News reports. The 68-year-old man faces charges of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence exposing another person to harm. Investigators claim he knew about the victim’s life-threatening allergy because they had been acquaintances for over two decades.
The incident began on August 14, 2025, when the victim found a greasy blue envelope in her driveway. She noticed the handwriting was unfamiliar and that it was addressed to her using an old residence. Upon opening the card, she found a brown substance smeared inside. She quickly identified it as peanut butter, dropped the envelope, and rushed to wash her hands. Despite her efforts, she developed hives on her arms and felt a tingling sensation for about six hours.
Police tracked the source of the mail by looking at the two Forever stamps attached to the envelope. A U.S. postal inspector helped trace the stamps to a self-service kiosk located at the Davie Post Office on South University Drive. Investigators found a 15-digit code on the stamps, which allowed them to identify the specific transaction. Records show the stamps were bought on August 8, 2025, using a Visa card belonging to Cancellare.
The kiosk also captured a photograph of the person making the purchase
When police showed the photograph to the victim, she identified the man as Cancellare. Other people who knew him, including an acquaintance from a band, also identified him in the image. Detectives noted that Cancellare wore sunglasses inside the post office to hide his identity. He also reportedly used a fake name and return address on the envelope.
The affidavit suggests the motive relates to a difficult divorce involving Cancellare and his wife. Although the victim was not his spouse, she was part of the same social circle. Witnesses told police that Cancellare had made comments to friends about wanting to hurt people connected to the situation. Because he had spent time with the victim and her spouse in social settings, he was reportedly well aware of the precautions she took to avoid peanuts at restaurants and gatherings.
The stamps were processed through a Miami postal facility on August 13, 2025, one day before the victim discovered the envelope. Detectives concluded that the act was a deliberate attempt to cause serious injury or death. After the investigation continued into 2026, officers obtained medical records and witness statements to build the case.
Plantation police found Cancellare at his home on November 13 to make the arrest. Officers took him to HCA Florida Westside Hospital for medical clearance before moving him to the Broward Sheriff’s Office main jail.
Published: Nov 16, 2026 10:30 am