81-year-old Missouri man James Barbier has been convicted of the murder of 18-year-old Karen Snider in 1966. On November 9, an Illinois jury found Barbier guilty of first-degree murder, just three days shy of the 60th anniversary of Snider’s death. He is scheduled to be sentenced next month.
On the evening of November 12, 1966, Karen’s husband, Paul Snider, returned home after finishing his shift at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad. Inside the couple’s two-story home on Wilson Avenue in Calumet City, Illinois, he found his wife dead with 125 stab wounds across her neck, chest, abdomen, and hands. Their two-month-old daughter, Paula, was lying unharmed nearby in her bassinet. Paul Snider later passed away in 1989.
“I hope that he never gets to breathe air outside again,” Paula Larson, Karen Snider’s now 60-year-old daughter, told the Chicago Tribune. “He didn’t give my mother a choice, and he got to live his life for 60 years.”
Barbier has been a suspect since the 1960s
As per CNN, James Barbier was first arrested in 1966, but was not charged. He was Paul’s co-worker and a friend of the couple. On the night of Karen’s murder, Barbier “appeared nervous” when he returned to his home in Gary, Indiana, and immediately removed his clothes and put them in the washing machine. His wife observed cuts on his face and hand, which were noticeable when he served as the pallbearer at Karen’s funeral.
Because forensic analysis was limited in the 1960’s, Karen’s murder remained unresolved for decades. In December 2022, police reopened the case after they received a call from Kevin Seeley, a relative of the Snider family, WBBM Newsradio reports. Seeley had grown up hearing the story of Karen’s murder from his grandmother.
“I was at work one day, and I was reading up on it, and I was like, ‘All right, maybe after 57 years, some sort of technology can be used to figure out who committed the crime,’” Seeley recalled. Per CBS, investigators obtained a DNA sample from Barbier in March 2023 and compared it with evidence preserved from the original investigation, including Karen’s clothing and bedsheet.
After forensic testing linked Barbier to the crime, he was arrested in April 2024 and charged with first-degree murder. “So many people have died in these 60 years,” said Paula Larson. “All that remains is the small family we have. And this is so very important to come to this verdict before we lost anybody else.”
Published: Nov 18, 2026 02:15 pm