Happy Valley, Broadchurch and Task are the strongest places to start if you’re looking for shows like Mare of Easttown. They understand that a crime drama becomes more compelling when the people investigating a case have to live with its consequences long after the police tape comes down.
Kate Winslet’s Mare Sheehan isn’t just solving a murder. She’s raising a family, carrying a devastating loss and working in a Pennsylvania community where she can barely question someone without encountering a shared history. The mystery matters because the town and its people feel worth knowing.
These ten recommendations match different parts of that appeal. Start with Happy Valley for another formidable, exhausted police officer, Broadchurch for a community shaken by a death, or Task for more Pennsylvania crime drama from Mare creator Brad Ingelsby.
1. Happy Valley
Sarah Lancashire’s Catherine Cawood is the closest match here for Mare herself: a capable police sergeant whose bluntness conceals considerable pain. Working in West Yorkshire while helping raise her grandson, Catherine cannot draw a clean line between the people she loves and the violence she encounters professionally.
The family scenes are as important as the investigations. Catherine can be funny, impatient and fiercely protective in the same conversation, and Lancashire makes those shifts feel like parts of a whole person. That combination should immediately appeal to anyone who loved Winslet’s performance.
Happy Valley builds an ongoing conflict across its three seasons, so it offers a longer relationship with its central characters than Mare‘s compact mystery. Its violence can also be more direct and sustained.
2. Broadchurch
The death of a young boy turns an English coastal town into a place where every familiar face might be hiding something. Olivia Colman’s Ellie Miller knows the community; David Tennant’s Alec Hardy arrives with less patience for the connections that complicate her work.
Like Mare of Easttown, Broadchurch treats suspicion as something that damages relationships even when it proves unfounded. The victim’s family remains central, keeping the investigation from becoming a guessing game detached from its human cost.
The biggest difference is the partnership. Where Mare is built around one woman’s life, Broadchurch gives its two investigators contrasting ways of approaching a town in mourning. Begin with the first season and avoid reading later-season descriptions beforehand.
3. Task
Brad Ingelsby’s Task returns to the working-class suburbs of Philadelphia, this time following an FBI team investigating violent robberies. Mark Ruffalo plays Tom Brandis, an agent dealing with a family tragedy while taking charge of the case.
The familiar element is Ingelsby’s attention to households under strain. Criminal decisions emerge from recognizable lives, and the investigation draws people into collisions that are more complicated than a straightforward division between good families and bad ones.
There is more emphasis on the people committing crimes than on concealing a killer’s identity. That makes Task a particularly good follow-up if you cared most about Mare‘s community and emotional fallout. Viewers drawn to that family-and-crime intersection can also explore our shows like Ozark.
4. Sharp Objects
Amy Adams plays Camille Preaker, a reporter sent back to her Missouri hometown to cover the deaths of two girls. Returning also means confronting her mother, her younger half-sister and a family history she has worked hard to keep at a distance.
The connection to Mare lies in how a community’s secrets become inseparable from its protagonist’s wounds. Camille’s reporting brings her closer to a case while making her own life harder to hold together.
This eight-episode adaptation of Gillian Flynn’s novel is more gothic and psychologically claustrophobic than a conventional police drama. Its treatment of self-harm and abuse is disturbing, and its slow pace asks viewers to pay attention to atmosphere and seemingly incidental details.
5. The Sinner
The Sinner is often more interested in why someone committed a crime than in hiding who did it. Its first season follows detective Harry Ambrose, played by Bill Pullman, as he investigates an apparently inexplicable act of violence by Jessica Biel’s Cora Tannetti.
That focus makes it a good match for viewers who found Mare‘s emotional revelations more memorable than its lineup of suspects. Ambrose keeps digging after an easy explanation becomes available, looking for the experiences that made a terrible moment possible.
Later seasons give him new cases. The anthology structure offers variety, although it means you won’t stay with one town and family network throughout the series.
6. The Night Of
A night out ends with Nasir Khan accused of murder, and the consequences spread through his family and the criminal justice system. Riz Ahmed plays Nasir, with John Turturro as the lawyer who becomes involved in his defense.
The Night Of shares Mare‘s interest in how a single death changes many lives. It also resists making an investigation feel neatly separate from money, prejudice and the institutions deciding whose story deserves belief.
Its New York setting and sustained attention to jail and legal procedure make it a different experience from a small-town detective series. Pick it when you want the same emotional weight with more focus on what happens to a suspect after an arrest.
7. Big Little Lies
A group of mothers in Monterey, California, appear to have comfortable lives until a death exposes the tensions running beneath their friendships and marriages. Reese Witherspoon, Nicole Kidman, Shailene Woodley, Laura Dern and Zoë Kravitz anchor the ensemble.
The setting is far wealthier than Easttown, but the interest in women protecting one another, hiding pain and making difficult family decisions provides a strong connection. Domestic abuse is a substantial part of the story, rather than just another secret in the mystery.
Expect sharper social comedy and more polished surroundings. The first season is the closest match for a tightly contained mystery whose resolution changes how earlier conversations read.
8. Under the Banner of Heaven
Andrew Garfield plays detective Jeb Pyre, whose investigation into the murders of a woman and her infant daughter unsettles his relationship with his faith. Gil Birmingham plays his fellow investigator Bill Taba.
Like Mare, Pyre has deep ties to the community he is questioning. That makes the investigation personally disruptive: understanding the crime means examining assumptions that have helped organize his own life.
The series draws on Jon Krakauer’s nonfiction book but uses dramatized characters and scenes, including Pyre. It moves between the investigation, family history and religious history, making it more structurally expansive than Mare. Its real-crime basis also gives the material a different weight.
9. The Undoing
Nicole Kidman’s Grace Fraser lives in a wealthy New York world that begins to collapse after a woman connected to her son’s school is killed. Hugh Grant plays her husband, Jonathan, whose role in Grace’s seemingly secure life comes under scrutiny.
The appeal for Mare fans is the uncomfortable question of how well anyone really knows the people closest to them. Family loyalty can clarify a person’s judgment, but it can also make obvious warning signs difficult to see.
The Undoing concentrates on privilege, marriage and courtroom suspense. It has less of Mare‘s lived-in community texture, but its six-episode story makes it a straightforward choice for another concentrated mystery.
10. The Outsider
A boy’s murder appears to have an obvious suspect until conflicting evidence makes the explanation difficult to sustain. Ben Mendelsohn’s Ralph Anderson and Cynthia Erivo’s Holly Gibney approach that problem from very different positions.
The early investigation, grieving families and suspicion surrounding a familiar local figure all recall Mare of Easttown. The crucial distinction is that The Outsider adapts Stephen King and embraces supernatural horror.
Its ten episodes are a good fit if you want a grounded-looking detective story that gradually becomes something stranger. If a realistic explanation for every clue is essential to your enjoyment, choose Broadchurch or Happy Valley instead.
Published: Dec 26, 2022 06:57 pm