One ‘Obi-Wan Kenobi’ character is splitting opinions right down the middle

The Third Sister
Image via Lucasfilm

Fans are loving Obi-Wan Kenobi‘s nuanced storytelling in the first two episodes, but one character is once again dividing opinions in the form of franchise newcomer Moses Ingram.

The story takes us 10 years after the Jedi Purge at the end of the Clone Wars, where Obi-Wan, now called Ben, is living with the trauma of failing his brother Anakin and the galaxy at large. He’s the self-professed protector of Luke Skywalker, but Obi-Wan has, in reality abandoned the Jedi Code to live out his life as a hermit.

That’s where the Inquisitors come into play. Rupert Friend’s Grand Inquisitor lands on Tatooine with two of his lackeys, the Fifth Brother and the Third Sister. They’re hunting a Jedi Knight who has sought shelter in the desert world, though Moses Ingram’s Third Sister is pursuing a mission of her own; to hunt down and bring Kenobi to Darth Vader.

The Jedi hunter has all the characteristics of a typical villain. A bit sadistic, completely uncaring, and just reckless enough to cause trouble for our titular hero. Unfortunately, all of these are also characteristics of a generic and shallow antagonist, which is why some Star Wars fans aren’t entirely sold on her being one of the major villains in Obi-Wan Kenobi.

Some users seem to think that her trying too hard is one of the things that can turn viewers off. The melodramatic balcony jumping scene, in particular, is something that stands out for a lot of people.

This is Star Wars, of course, and no one opinion is something that the entire fandom can get behind. In fact, a lot of folks are actually impressed with Ingram’s character and her acting.

There are already some strong opinions about the Third Sister being the worst thing that has happened to Star Wars, even worse than Disney’s infamous sequel trilogy. Typical.

It’s perhaps true that people always find something to complain about, but Star Wars fans are especially susceptible to that harsh critical outlook. And with good reason, too, given Disney’s track record.

At any rate, the Third Sister is officially the first controversial thing about Obi-Wan Kenobi.