Sink Your Teeth Into These Shows Just Like ‘Vampire Diaries'
Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.

10 shows like The Vampire Diaries for supernatural romance

It's time to sink your teeth into these awesome shows whose characters, themes, and moods will remind you of 'The Vampire Diaries.'
This article is over 4 years old and may contain outdated information

The Originals and Legacies are the natural next steps after The Vampire Diaries, but they are not the only ways to find that mix of supernatural danger and complicated romance. Teen Wolf is a strong choice for the teen friendships, A Discovery of Witches for forbidden love, and True Blood for a more explicit adult alternative.

Elena, Stefan, and Damon made Mystic Falls compelling because the supernatural rules always had personal consequences. A family secret could change a relationship, a dangerous attraction could divide friends, and protecting somebody often created another problem. The best shows like The Vampire Diaries understand that the monsters matter most when you care about the people involved.

These ten picks prioritize that connection between relationships and the supernatural. Some stay close to the teen-drama formula, while others trade school life for adult romance, gothic horror, or the everyday difficulties of being something other than human.

Legacies

Legacies returns to Mystic Falls through the Salvatore School for the Young and Gifted, where Hope Mikaelson and other supernatural students try to manage their abilities alongside the pressures of growing up.

It is a good continuation for viewers who miss young characters building friendships while keeping extraordinary secrets. The school gives the ensemble a shared home, and questions of belonging become as important as the next threat. The difference is the show’s more playful approach to fantasy, with a broader assortment of creatures and more individual monster-focused adventures. Watching The Originals first provides useful context for Hope, while keeping the emphasis on discovery rather than having the earlier family story spoiled.

The Originals

The closest match is already part of the same universe. The Originals moves the focus to the Mikaelson family in New Orleans, where Klaus and his relatives become entangled in conflicts involving vampires, witches, and werewolves.

The appeal is familiar: old grudges keep resurfacing, affection does not stop people from hurting each other, and protecting the family can become an excuse for almost anything. The main difference is emphasis. The Originals is more concerned with dynastic loyalty, parenthood, and control of a city than with the school-age relationships that anchor the beginning of The Vampire Diaries. If the Mikaelsons were the characters who made you pay closer attention, start here.

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina

Sabrina Spellman is caught between her mortal life and her witch heritage, with friends, family, and powerful supernatural institutions all making competing demands on her. She wants to retain her relationships without accepting every rule imposed on her.

That refusal to choose neatly between two worlds gives Chilling Adventures of Sabrina a clear connection to The Vampire Diaries. A supposedly simple romantic or personal decision can quickly become a question of supernatural allegiance. The difference is its stronger commitment to occult horror, ritual, and dark fantasy. This is not the light sitcom version of Sabrina. Choose it when you want the teen relationships but also want the magic itself to feel threatening and oppressive.

Shadowhunters

Clary discovers a hidden world of demon hunters and supernatural beings beneath the New York she thought she knew. Learning about her own place in that world complicates both her existing relationships and the new connections she makes.

Like Elena’s introduction to the secrets of Mystic Falls, Clary’s discoveries are personal before they become part of a larger conflict. Family history and attraction can change whom she trusts. Shadowhunters is more openly an action-fantasy adventure, with a demon-hunting organization and a wider system of supernatural factions. It is a good option if you want romantic complications alongside missions, training, and the gradual discovery of a hidden society, rather than another story centered on vampire brothers.

Being Human (2011)

The North American version of Being Human follows Aidan, a vampire; Josh, a werewolf; and Sally, a ghost, as they try to share a home and maintain some connection to ordinary life. Their problems cannot be solved simply by finding the right person to fight.

The show is a strong match for the parts of The Vampire Diaries concerned with restraint, guilt, and the fear of hurting someone you love. Its difference is the domestic focus. Being supernatural affects daily routines and the possibility of a normal future, not just dramatic confrontations. Specify the 2011 version when looking it up, since it adapts an earlier British series. For more hidden-world stories with an adult ensemble, our shows like Grimm guide has additional options.

Teen Wolf

Scott McCall’s life changes after a werewolf bite gives him abilities he does not know how to control. Suddenly, school, friendships, and romantic interests have to coexist with a dangerous supernatural identity.

That struggle makes Teen Wolf one of the closest matches outside the Vampire Diaries universe. Scott’s relationships matter because he needs people he can trust, not just people who can fight beside him. The show also builds a wider mythology beyond its initial werewolf premise. Compared with the romantic rivalries in Mystic Falls, the friendship between Scott and Stiles and the bonds within the larger group carry more of the emotional weight. Expect more pack dynamics and physical action.

Interview with the Vampire (2022)

AMC’s adaptation of Anne Rice’s novel begins with Louis de Pointe du Lac recounting his life to journalist Daniel Molloy. His history with Lestat gives the story a central relationship shaped by desire, power, dependence, and resentment.

This is the pick for viewers who want the emotional danger of vampire romance examined more closely. Attraction does not erase cruelty, and the act of remembering a relationship can become part of the drama. Compared with The Vampire Diaries, the tone is more adult, the storytelling more reflective, and the focus more concentrated on the people telling and challenging the story. It offers gothic intimacy and disturbing relationship dynamics rather than a fast rotation of high-school romances and supernatural crises.

A Discovery of Witches

Diana Bishop is a historian trying to keep her distance from witchcraft when a mysterious manuscript pulls her into the supernatural world. Her connection with vampire Matthew Clairmont becomes dangerous in a society where the boundaries between different kinds of creatures are closely guarded.

If forbidden love was your favorite part of The Vampire Diaries, this is a strong fit. The romance has consequences beyond the couple, and history is something that can return to threaten the present. The pace is more measured, the protagonists are adults, and scholarship is central to Diana’s part in the mystery. Its historical dimension also makes it a natural companion to the romantic dramas in our guide to shows like Outlander.

True Blood

Telepathic waitress Sookie Stackhouse becomes involved with vampires in the Louisiana town of Bon Temps, where attraction and fear make an already complicated community even more volatile. Her ability to hear other people’s thoughts gives her own relationships an unusual starting point.

The dangerous romances and hidden histories will be familiar to Vampire Diaries fans, but True Blood is a much more explicit watch. Sex, violence, and grotesque humor are prominent, and the story concerns adults rather than high-school students. Its vampires also exist within a public debate about how humans should treat them. Choose this for the small-town supernatural soap opera, with the expectation that the tone is considerably more lurid and confrontational.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Buffy Summers has the skills and responsibility to fight vampires, but she still has to deal with school, friends, and the desire for a life that is not organized around saving everyone else. Sunnydale makes those wishes particularly difficult to reconcile.

Buffy is an especially good choice if you liked how The Vampire Diaries turned ordinary anxieties about love and identity into supernatural dilemmas. The central difference is perspective: Buffy is the person expected to confront the danger, even when her own feelings make that duty painful. The series also makes more room for standalone creatures, sharp comedy, and stories that experiment with the usual format. Romance matters, but it is part of a wider struggle over responsibility.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
More Stories To Read
Author
Author
Image of Asmir Pekmic
Asmir Pekmic
Asmir is a gaming writer with 16 years of experience covering the video game industry, specializing in news, guides, and live-service games. When he’s not writing or playing video games, he enjoys running and playing basketball.