Kentucky Little Caesars customer loses it, causes $1k in damages, over the price of extra sauce, cops allege

Look, we get it, things are expensive these days, but there’s no reason to cause over $1,000 in damages to a Little Caesars restaurant, just as police allege a woman did this year when she found out extra sauce would cost her $1 extra.

Taylor was arrested in September in a separate incident related to the father of her child, when she allegedly threw a brick at the car of the father of her child, again causing over $1,000 in damages.

The Little Caesars tantrum

Before her arrest, in January 2025, Breanna Taylor, 32, from Louisville, Kentucky, placed a phone order at a Little Caesars in the city. Once at Little Caesars, when Taylor arrived to pick up her order, she requested extra sauce. When informed that there would be a $1 charge, Haynes reportedly became irate. Surveillance footage captured her knocking items off the counter, including a custom-made computer stand and the computer register. Thankfully, no one got hurt.

The restaurant’s employees provided police with Haynes’s name after comparing the surveillance footage with a known photograph. She was charged with first-degree criminal mischief, but was not arrested until months later in connection to the brick-throwing incident.

She now faces first-degree criminal mischief charges related to the Little Caesars outburst, and additional charges of assault and criminal mischief for the attack on the father of her child’s car. Police say she is also accused of “putting her hands” on the man and “causing him pain internally.”