What looked like a string of family tragedies spanning nearly two decades was later tied by investigators to life insurance payouts. The case of Karl Karlsen, who was convicted in the deaths of his first wife and their son, was revisited on Oxygen’s Dateline: Secrets Uncovered, as recapped by Yahoo News.
The pattern started on New Year’s Day 1991 in the rural town of Murphys, California, with the death of 30-year-old Christina Karlsen. She died of smoke inhalation as a result of a fast-moving fire that engulfed her family’s mountain home.
Karl said he was in the garage when he heard Christina scream. He went in and pulled the three kids out through the windows, while his wife was stuck behind a boarded-up window in the bathroom, where she’d been having a bath.
A tight budget stopped investigators from following up
Although State Fire Investigator Carl Kent did detect a very strong smell of kerosene outside the bathroom door and noted that the burn patterns were suspicious, he was constrained by agency budgetary considerations. These prevented him from traveling to Seneca Falls, NY, where Karl had moved the family just four days after the fire, to conduct a follow-up interview. The fire was ultimately ruled accidental.
Seventeen years later, on Nov. 20, 2008, another death hit the family in New York. Karl’s 23-year-old son, Levi Karlsen, was found pinned under a pickup truck in the barn after Karl and his second wife, Cindy Best, returned from a funeral. Cindy called 911, and she later said Karl seemed “very distraught.”
Karl collected $700,000 in life insurance as the named beneficiary on Levi’s policy. Cindy grew increasingly suspicious of her husband and hired a private investigator, and in February 2012, one of her friends called the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office, which opened its own investigation.
Investigators learned the $700,000 policy on Levi had been issued just 17 days before his death, and that two additional policies had been taken out on Levi’s two daughters. In a conversation Cindy secretly recorded, Karl denied pushing the truck onto Levi but admitted he “took advantage of the situation once it happened.” Under questioning, he told detectives he walked out and left his son under the truck, and later said he may have caused it to tip over by opening the vehicle’s door.
On Nov. 6, 2013, one day before his trial was set to start, Karl pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in Levi’s death and was sentenced to 15 years to life. That conviction gave investigators in California the push they needed to take a fresh look at Christina’s case.
He continues to blame the deaths on bad luck
Using the files Kent had held onto, investigators re-examined the evidence and concluded Karl had deliberately set the fire to kill his wife and collect an insurance payout. He was charged with first-degree murder in Calaveras County in August 2014 and convicted in Feb. 2020, receiving a life sentence.
Just as Levi’s policy was issued less than three weeks before the truck fell on him, Karl had taken out a $200,000 life insurance policy on Christina just 19 days before the 1991 house fire. He also collected nearly $115,000 in insurance after a 2002 barn fire in New York killed three of the family’s Belgian draft horses, a fire that was ruled an accident after a brief investigation.
Published: Nov 20, 2026 04:30 am