9 Reasons Why Birdman Deserved To Win Best Picture

Birdman's triumph at the Academy Awards polarized audiences, just like the film. Here, in a defence, are several reasons why it deserved the top prize.

9) It has one of the year’s most unforgettable (and endlessly debatable) final scenes

Recommended Videos

emmastonebirdman

I know a lot of people who loved Birdman until the final scene. It’s one that deserves a lot of discussion. With Iñárritu’s interest in exploring the mix between the real and the magical, there are, naturally, several interpretations of what happened with Riggan in the hospital.

(SPOILERS AHEAD)

Regardless of whether you think the last few minutes of the film indicate that Riggan is alive or dead, the abrupt finish is something close to perfect. Films that end on an ambiguous note can aggravate audiences (and it seems like, for several viewers, Birdman was no exception). Still, considering the magical realist elements within the dark comedy, a tidy wrap-up would have been far more ill-suited.

In the scene, Riggan lies in a hospital bed, after shooting himself on stage. Jake and his family are relieved to see him, with Sam walking in with the flowers she was supposed to buy him in the opening scene. In this sequence, Riggan obtains all that he dreams of: a rapturous review in the New York Times, the love of his ex-wife and daughter, the attention of a public interested in seeing whether he is doing well, no Birdman voice haunting his psyche. The final scene recalls the text that opens the film, from Raymond Carver’s “Late Fragment”:

And did you get what you wanted from this life, even so?
I did.
And what did you want?
To call myself beloved, to feel myself beloved on the earth.

In this writer’s interpretation of the last scene, this entire sequence – finishing with an implied leap out of a window – does not take place in the real world, but in Riggan’s mind. Everything is just a little too perfect and complete to read the scene as literal, rather than a manifestation.

However you look at this moment, it spawned vigorous debate among film fans. It is strange and surreal, but gave filmgoers a spark of discussion – something that can be sorely missing from more mainstream titles that do too much to cater to the whims and needs of the audience, and too little to challenge us. It was a fantastic way to finish off a film that often made us question what was real and what was make-believe.


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more
related content
Read Article ‘My day is ruined’: This furry surprise is every foodie’s grossest nightmare come to life
Screenshots of a post from TikTok user @funkyfrogbait
Read Article Oliver Stone’s 10 Best Films
platoon-1986
Read Article 5 Marvel characters Emma Corrin could be playing in ‘Deadpool 3’
Read Article ‘The Rings of Power’ EP promises a darker, grittier, and scarier second season
the lord of the rings sauron
Read Article What is the new student debt relief plan? How to sign up for student loan forgiveness, explained
Protest for student debt relief
Related Content
Read Article ‘My day is ruined’: This furry surprise is every foodie’s grossest nightmare come to life
Screenshots of a post from TikTok user @funkyfrogbait
Read Article Oliver Stone’s 10 Best Films
platoon-1986
Read Article 5 Marvel characters Emma Corrin could be playing in ‘Deadpool 3’
Read Article ‘The Rings of Power’ EP promises a darker, grittier, and scarier second season
the lord of the rings sauron
Read Article What is the new student debt relief plan? How to sign up for student loan forgiveness, explained
Protest for student debt relief
Author
Jordan Adler
Jordan Adler is a film buff who consumes so much popcorn, he expects that a coroner's report will one day confirm that butter runs through his veins. A recent graduate of Carleton's School of Journalism, where he also majored in film studies, Jordan's writing has been featured in Tribute Magazine, the Canadian Jewish News, Marketing Magazine, Toronto Film Scene, ANDPOP and SamaritanMag.com. He is also working on a feature-length screenplay.