Are Kuina and Tashigi the same person in ‘One Piece?’

With over two decades of history, One Piece has introduced a gigantic medley of characters into its jumbled story.

From zombies to fishmen the story created and illustrated by Eiichiro Oda quickly became known for its longevity but most of all, its intricate and complex, well-rounded characters. Each protagonist and antagonist has a thoroughly explored backstory filled with goulash adventures in its midst, as is the case for one of One Piece‘s most beloved characters: Zoro, the Straw Hats’ swordsman.

Who are Tashigi and Kuina in One Piece?

Though mysterious to some inattentive eyes, Oda has been exploring Zoro’s past and present throughout One Piece. As the writer introduced Shimotsuki Village, the small place where Zoro grew up, Oda also included a few details regarding Zoro’s childhood friend, Kuina, an ambitious and headstrong girl who wishes to become the strongest swordswoman in history.

Later in the story, Zoro meets someone who reminds him of his late friend, and despite being his opponent, Tashigi is almost identical to Kuina in more ways than one. Their headstrong personality, ambitious nature, and even their appearance are eerily similar, but are they the same person?

Is Kuina really alive?

Yes, Kuina is dead, but that hasn’t stopped any One Piece fan from theorizing about her. As for her passing, Kuina’s dream of becoming a swordswoman fell short after she allegedly made a misstep while on the stairs. I say ‘allegedly’ because, as many Japanese fans pointed out through the years, using the phrase “fell off the stairs,” often indicates that someone has taken their own life.

Nonetheless, Kuina was pronounced dead at the scene. Kuina and Zoro’s last interaction would drive him for the rest of his life, spurring the pirate to swear to become a master swordsman in memory of his late friend, rival, and relative. To this day, Kuina is still the very reason why Zoro thrives to be the best swordsman in the world.

Are Tashigi and Kuina the same person?

Despite sharing the same age and even appearance, Kuina and Tashigi are not the same person. With a very obvious intention behind their character design, Oda’s choice for Tashigi’s appearance was intended to hint at her becoming a rival to Zoro, reminiscent of his friend. Upon facing the swordsman, Tashigi swears she will defeat him one day, thus inspiring the admiral to become stronger in the awakening of their imminent battle.

Besides, Tashigi’s last name was never disclosed for possibly being unimportant information, whereas Kuina’s ancestry derives from a long family of swordsmen – the same bloodline as Zoro. Many have also pointed out that if they were the same person, it wouldn’t be the first time Oda would bring back to life a previously believed deceased character. However, Kuina’s deceased body confirmed her passing.

While no one but Oda and his team knows the truth, all speculation is welcome with the several theories thoroughly backed by many fans on Reddit and Twitter alike. All in all, it is still assumed that Kuina and Tashigi are entirely different individuals.